{ "updated": "2026-10-11", "dataThrough": "2026-09-24", "runs": [ { "id": "cams_benchmark_2026", "source": "TROPOMI", "dates": [ "2026-01-21", "2026-05-07" ], "initializations": 107, "rows": [ { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 12.46205668849943, "mae": 8.313014189229214, "bias": -1.8742829412555617, "n": 22425301 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 9.77931038550372, "mae": 6.521778657766148, "bias": -1.3094003091161095, "n": 4485072 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 11.080360219851869, "mae": 7.529254054394077, "bias": -1.8473706984598268, "n": 4485228 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 12.099378396631016, "mae": 8.242299575322667, "bias": -1.9902287110349874, "n": 4485255 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 13.324617280636517, "mae": 9.02207367503176, "bias": -2.055092836085465, "n": 4485046 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 15.302704743942654, "mae": 10.249859885631002, "bias": -2.1693438778680196, "n": 4484700 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 17.856797720743664, "mae": 12.373555928174104, "bias": -7.457325948337096, "n": 22425301 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 16.751166826556602, "mae": 11.642536531416514, "bias": -7.034313591063513, "n": 4485072 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 17.10457258218759, "mae": 11.917954855430427, "bias": -7.366271242040652, "n": 4485228 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 17.54547176748997, "mae": 12.23339726122141, "bias": -7.540166516555662, "n": 4485255 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 18.29853127008844, "mae": 12.694890656350138, "bias": -7.643306838108707, "n": 4485046 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 19.454683413139666, "mae": 13.37910716697051, "bias": -7.702592761930549, "n": 4484700 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 27.194417186185394, "mae": 17.2575110264167, "bias": 0.10581260098227815, "n": 22425301 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 19.677398819314448, "mae": 12.027945761582503, "bias": 0.06359710432143986, "n": 4485072 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 25.747915955155147, "mae": 16.330589569101647, "bias": 0.07350270504237723, "n": 4485228 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 28.33284115009649, "mae": 18.329777993521635, "bias": 0.0978121742384419, "n": 4485255 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 29.700681146579477, "mae": 19.36584364474076, "bias": 0.13275370896163058, "n": 4485046 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 31.026851269695623, "mae": 20.23364572073397, "bias": 0.16140352957569842, "n": 4484700 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 10.810514212795029, "mae": 6.902729092322351, "bias": -1.223327960680939, "n": 14977745 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 8.58008921191375, "mae": 5.469088558587158, "bias": -0.8553738232605557, "n": 2995561 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 9.612704345211567, "mae": 6.2711001357719045, "bias": -1.200499756843072, "n": 2995610 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 10.442909726252365, "mae": 6.83538559938099, "bias": -1.2771301218501505, "n": 2995614 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 11.504169128688616, "mae": 7.462991042043134, "bias": -1.3438334664622493, "n": 2995540 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 13.30102684005008, "mae": 8.475170680308684, "bias": -1.4398132530385108, "n": 2995418 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 16.277103956364137, "mae": 11.129582968857779, "bias": -7.6436763704231465, "n": 14977745 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 15.348400644465872, "mae": 10.550373422037284, "bias": -7.365664063940508, "n": 2995561 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 15.659343054886463, "mae": 10.78384286571427, "bias": -7.585859092523591, "n": 2995610 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 16.025898696874417, "mae": 11.030266421727886, "bias": -7.699591185977379, "n": 2995614 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 16.643462901544613, "mae": 11.379869062373913, "bias": -7.766836143337891, "n": 2995540 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 17.609672316693587, "mae": 11.903609201593571, "bias": -7.800439686779004, "n": 2995418 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 24.429400135050667, "mae": 14.547473252037078, "bias": -0.07490187463559358, "n": 14977745 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 18.10781942746011, "mae": 10.337579317225082, "bias": 0.014703541841441318, "n": 2995561 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 23.428182631075394, "mae": 13.896245137810519, "bias": -0.040233744416114506, "n": 2995610 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 25.498359976934694, "mae": 15.477754165679281, "bias": -0.07967366712482561, "n": 2995614 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 26.479321085229273, "mae": 16.212594504014856, "bias": -0.11349536684360921, "n": 2995540 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 27.493498549822977, "mae": 16.81330740516599, "bias": -0.1558147561919685, "n": 2995418 } ], "stations": null }, { "id": "omps_benchmark_2026", "source": "OMPS", "dates": [ "2026-01-21", "2026-05-07" ], "initializations": 107, "rows": [ { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 20.829775332779985, "mae": 14.38446475135702, "bias": 4.210577673484258, "n": 21366651 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 20.4922180495987, "mae": 14.06429879207609, "bias": 4.7722488897732065, "n": 4272668 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 20.460639474835855, "mae": 14.104053445130669, "bias": 4.249858030489782, "n": 4273423 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 20.61283085637372, "mae": 14.266439066880352, "bias": 4.105625660015043, "n": 4273796 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 20.880464463119853, "mae": 14.491607301461464, "bias": 4.021745248194319, "n": 4273626 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 21.678260239435257, "mae": 14.995914576936649, "bias": 3.9035074230697706, "n": 4273138 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 25.075162554554293, "mae": 16.10843287412291, "bias": -1.777783338704701, "n": 21366651 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 24.743429138611507, "mae": 15.871724288091313, "bias": -1.3636243803132329, "n": 4272668 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 24.84444098763837, "mae": 15.955126448861407, "bias": -1.6810019541857897, "n": 4273423 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 24.971975327121406, "mae": 16.060718573215443, "bias": -1.855003622796945, "n": 4273796 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 25.20566187540497, "mae": 16.197488353503182, "bias": -1.959642660002187, "n": 4273626 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 25.600964945526346, "mae": 16.45708807338441, "bias": -2.0295723185822365, "n": 4273138 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 30.53092040020753, "mae": 20.54638734104625, "bias": 6.133506907983482, "n": 21366651 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 27.18685039446615, "mae": 18.21357602634311, "bias": 6.086208463814314, "n": 4272668 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 29.478468710233212, "mae": 19.890152859015572, "bias": 6.106598958023898, "n": 4273423 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 30.627892226374914, "mae": 20.731787780767345, "bias": 6.130462327609018, "n": 4273796 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 31.867881263096287, "mae": 21.533756659066846, "bias": 6.1567329454943, "n": 4273626 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 33.150014398439176, "mae": 22.362309255222577, "bias": 6.187526253657405, "n": 4273138 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 19.003323369346734, "mae": 12.856658523712474, "bias": 5.035274844974071, "n": 14598099 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 18.877805517976903, "mae": 12.720970021350121, "bias": 5.422325173025684, "n": 2918893 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 18.804113915257116, "mae": 12.701125562319314, "bias": 5.076530380911972, "n": 2919578 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 18.847463121310014, "mae": 12.775045095298417, "bias": 4.985999176849735, "n": 2919991 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 18.964824962001504, "mae": 12.884540203634126, "bias": 4.898152740773505, "n": 2919923 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 19.513400288288718, "mae": 13.201572305148442, "bias": 4.793491800998276, "n": 2919712 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 22.567463718197907, "mae": 13.778756852998413, "bias": -1.4841506170746863, "n": 14598099 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 22.323450938263196, "mae": 13.617939898067386, "bias": -1.1822220169026, "n": 2918893 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 22.394469738123167, "mae": 13.674462060326263, "bias": -1.4105074041484318, "n": 2919578 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 22.48687531498255, "mae": 13.746027722203191, "bias": -1.5395563649146895, "n": 2919991 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 22.666704335031064, "mae": 13.836703153295248, "bias": -1.620296191344593, "n": 2919923 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 22.95998481674526, "mae": 14.018600474077179, "bias": -1.6680679262879843, "n": 2919712 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 27.477225475243515, "mae": 17.853836870890625, "bias": 6.183578788061484, "n": 14598099 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 24.83398185128825, "mae": 16.12201670117002, "bias": 6.285002406895072, "n": 2918893 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 26.69940950810279, "mae": 17.41871363705863, "bias": 6.235617918027027, "n": 2919578 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 27.542204312186186, "mae": 17.99669465306826, "bias": 6.184884957534782, "n": 2919991 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 28.515163558527792, "mae": 18.555972662153522, "bias": 6.1317268784380525, "n": 2919923 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 29.55793722524466, "mae": 19.17521667745608, "bias": 6.080696235237607, "n": 2919712 } ], "stations": null }, { "id": "woudc_benchmark_2026", "source": "WOUDC", "dates": [ "2026-01-21", "2026-05-07" ], "initializations": 107, "rows": [ { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 19.190047083970523, "mae": 13.593054863106813, "bias": 0.8415284390855313, "n": 13772 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 17.526868989668603, "mae": 12.253595590505576, "bias": 1.7314973583228304, "n": 2777 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 17.814357359960177, "mae": 12.63331128893168, "bias": 0.9888288206505137, "n": 2762 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 18.545923667170022, "mae": 13.201500630023133, "bias": 0.5931622618629786, "n": 2749 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 19.846235723114912, "mae": 14.174746964156672, "bias": 0.5271152571353788, "n": 2746 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 21.914871184902605, "mae": 15.729485187850964, "bias": 0.35498712287496004, "n": 2738 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 24.204664077209824, "mae": 16.820370760830965, "bias": -6.129158139678928, "n": 13772 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 23.234749146674165, "mae": 16.133226932447336, "bias": -5.931684187002048, "n": 2777 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 23.290342362630742, "mae": 16.183631626270028, "bias": -6.109555365295189, "n": 2762 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 23.44124445273463, "mae": 16.336484068825097, "bias": -6.286355666309411, "n": 2749 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 24.553720753149648, "mae": 17.119688818946166, "bias": -6.118141524390591, "n": 2746 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 26.377841198637263, "mae": 18.345260837462977, "bias": -6.202439240594255, "n": 2738 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 34.3258535815715, "mae": 24.18061127941033, "bias": 2.098583534987486, "n": 13772 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 29.15981575721672, "mae": 19.782838007508314, "bias": 2.4332872609848337, "n": 2777 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 33.802422558663416, "mae": 23.662709589025233, "bias": 1.9675923816368772, "n": 2762 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 35.53920895363843, "mae": 25.21836984578199, "bias": 1.8555881559913832, "n": 2749 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 35.91411969422813, "mae": 25.818487641069893, "bias": 2.0865307201543866, "n": 2746 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 36.74072355288458, "mae": 26.47887791814031, "bias": 2.1473113088559024, "n": 2738 } ], "stations": 38 }, { "id": "cams_benchmark_2026_nrti_full", "source": "TROPOMI", "dates": [ "2026-01-21", "2026-05-07" ], "initializations": 107, "rows": [ { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 13.032980770933325, "mae": 8.64520154527615, "bias": -1.4624359666421063, "n": 22226717 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 10.30875299038274, "mae": 6.814843371233133, "bias": -1.0004058915028862, "n": 4445208 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 11.693001269371406, "mae": 7.864346941906179, "bias": -1.4257720933041425, "n": 4445411 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 12.729873254291798, "mae": 8.592739385892349, "bias": -1.5371121611703096, "n": 4445469 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 13.938952990381305, "mae": 9.381160536916122, "bias": -1.615934663677185, "n": 4445414 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 15.809898844150112, "mae": 10.572919088678315, "bias": -1.7329447738638175, "n": 4445215 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 16.864657119225683, "mae": 11.140881732716732, "bias": -6.1312672281705565, "n": 22226717 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 15.605536962027548, "mae": 10.275832436421322, "bias": -5.702020944402399, "n": 4445208 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 16.027796389163573, "mae": 10.614895502905727, "bias": -6.034231710632604, "n": 4445411 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 16.53336111520525, "mae": 10.997254394119302, "bias": -6.212822909814755, "n": 4445469 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 17.36424014452046, "mae": 11.524169274708592, "bias": -6.319423271992597, "n": 4445414 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 18.622363121970253, "mae": 12.292269933338812, "bias": -6.38782782326351, "n": 4445215 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 27.200494143218375, "mae": 17.200380461504082, "bias": 0.12413856998589058, "n": 22226717 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 19.836854506254497, "mae": 12.086545081602283, "bias": 0.12211107799175829, "n": 4445208 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 25.781004712355646, "mae": 16.303296066928386, "bias": 0.11933779859534985, "n": 4445411 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 28.32473726109361, "mae": 18.260370930712984, "bias": 0.1303088939646889, "n": 4445469 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 29.677490122836183, "mae": 19.267092011991902, "bias": 0.1365496351429859, "n": 4445414 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 30.953548151958106, "mae": 20.084476629031144, "bias": 0.11238474453724069, "n": 4445215 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 10.908667043005147, "mae": 6.949614226698378, "bias": -0.4501554705124944, "n": 14880190 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 8.757635540972686, "mae": 5.553165373103145, "bias": -0.30548467379694805, "n": 2975993 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 9.767597977515223, "mae": 6.335369712174849, "bias": -0.44392136727097564, "n": 2976070 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 10.571211449528976, "mae": 6.887894590328335, "bias": -0.44274100137217315, "n": 2976078 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 11.595524304673878, "mae": 7.504177714474274, "bias": -0.4895326694913781, "n": 2976059 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 13.292360069407449, "mae": 8.467472394034441, "bias": -0.5690973963534288, "n": 2975987 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 14.97666607556507, "mae": 9.482723917324083, "bias": -5.262885918033835, "n": 14880190 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 13.977276087052832, "mae": 8.824750741988108, "bias": -4.972903714973884, "n": 2975993 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 14.303488196435719, "mae": 9.08811056738182, "bias": -5.1983724829262306, "n": 2976070 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 14.699427363599169, "mae": 9.379230604124817, "bias": -5.319503036737393, "n": 2976078 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 15.369848236876374, "mae": 9.770581208884911, "bias": -5.391446820510311, "n": 2976059 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 16.40864984377418, "mae": 10.35095512492416, "bias": -5.432201115301848, "n": 2975987 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 24.26053712253477, "mae": 14.39793791076459, "bias": -0.013595191448282522, "n": 14880190 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 18.16340432727029, "mae": 10.30814634055496, "bias": 0.09619276810850129, "n": 2975993 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 23.30244797733219, "mae": 13.769901762580817, "bias": 0.03502157406804418, "n": 2976070 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 25.309372786669673, "mae": 15.310963881071618, "bias": -0.011924672819565841, "n": 2976078 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 26.257178107616088, "mae": 16.025253008878046, "bias": -0.0546969759641857, "n": 2976059 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 27.202003783175556, "mae": 16.57538351856742, "bias": -0.13256930271948217, "n": 2975987 } ], "stations": null }, { "id": "cams_benchmark_2026_nrti_o3_hybrid", "source": "TROPOMI", "dates": [ "2026-01-21", "2026-05-07" ], "initializations": 107, "rows": [ { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 13.083882539867073, "mae": 8.687023409683674, "bias": -1.7144060640883858, "n": 22226717 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 10.353724850971867, "mae": 6.844170233279921, "bias": -1.173028218588091, "n": 4445208 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 11.749995481328115, "mae": 7.906366278265012, "bias": -1.6765590999826592, "n": 4445411 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 12.78610957476783, "mae": 8.637275443106539, "bias": -1.8158603735848189, "n": 4445469 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 13.993670449412438, "mae": 9.42853753479054, "bias": -1.8933424555681102, "n": 4445414 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 15.854689714383948, "mae": 10.618768725061267, "bias": -2.013227181360921, "n": 4445215 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 16.864657119225683, "mae": 11.140881732716732, "bias": -6.1312672281705565, "n": 22226717 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 15.605536962027548, "mae": 10.275832436421322, "bias": -5.702020944402399, "n": 4445208 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 16.027796389163573, "mae": 10.614895502905727, "bias": -6.034231710632604, "n": 4445411 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 16.53336111520525, "mae": 10.997254394119302, "bias": -6.212822909814755, "n": 4445469 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 17.36424014452046, "mae": 11.524169274708592, "bias": -6.319423271992597, "n": 4445414 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 18.622363121970253, "mae": 12.292269933338812, "bias": -6.38782782326351, "n": 4445215 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 27.200494143218375, "mae": 17.200380461504082, "bias": 0.12413856998589058, "n": 22226717 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 19.836854506254497, "mae": 12.086545081602283, "bias": 0.12211107799175829, "n": 4445208 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 25.781004712355646, "mae": 16.303296066928386, "bias": 0.11933779859534985, "n": 4445411 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 28.32473726109361, "mae": 18.260370930712984, "bias": 0.1303088939646889, "n": 4445469 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 29.677490122836183, "mae": 19.267092011991902, "bias": 0.1365496351429859, "n": 4445414 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 30.953548151958106, "mae": 20.084476629031144, "bias": 0.11238474453724069, "n": 4445215 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 10.946998266530427, "mae": 6.965194458471785, "bias": -0.6303873460746384, "n": 14880190 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 8.799362450749657, "mae": 5.565351562906341, "bias": -0.4249573832003782, "n": 2975993 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 9.81088361912735, "mae": 6.35156133716262, "bias": -0.6243637931699062, "n": 2976070 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 10.610879582125738, "mae": 6.903601666748217, "bias": -0.6450856695878341, "n": 2976078 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 11.633757028864549, "mae": 7.520901854270554, "bias": -0.6869636563822696, "n": 2976059 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 13.325433115737026, "mae": 8.484564480410848, "bias": -0.770565013387007, "n": 2975987 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 14.97666607556507, "mae": 9.482723917324083, "bias": -5.262885918033835, "n": 14880190 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 13.977276087052832, "mae": 8.824750741988108, "bias": -4.972903714973884, "n": 2975993 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 14.303488196435719, "mae": 9.08811056738182, "bias": -5.1983724829262306, "n": 2976070 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 14.699427363599169, "mae": 9.379230604124817, "bias": -5.319503036737393, "n": 2976078 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 15.369848236876374, "mae": 9.770581208884911, "bias": -5.391446820510311, "n": 2976059 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 16.40864984377418, "mae": 10.35095512492416, "bias": -5.432201115301848, "n": 2975987 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 24.26053712253477, "mae": 14.39793791076459, "bias": -0.013595191448282522, "n": 14880190 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 18.16340432727029, "mae": 10.30814634055496, "bias": 0.09619276810850129, "n": 2975993 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 23.30244797733219, "mae": 13.769901762580817, "bias": 0.03502157406804418, "n": 2976070 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 25.309372786669673, "mae": 15.310963881071618, "bias": -0.011924672819565841, "n": 2976078 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 26.257178107616088, "mae": 16.025253008878046, "bias": -0.0546969759641857, "n": 2976059 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 27.202003783175556, "mae": 16.57538351856742, "bias": -0.13256930271948217, "n": 2975987 } ], "stations": null }, { "id": "woudc_benchmark_2026_nrti_full", "source": "WOUDC", "dates": [ "2026-01-21", "2026-05-07" ], "initializations": 107, "rows": [ { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 19.16459576867652, "mae": 13.492860398821213, "bias": -0.8596969213241186, "n": 13845 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 17.341462015101715, "mae": 12.020954557455068, "bias": -0.21387629134546432, "n": 2789 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 17.800397207606732, "mae": 12.554279328767244, "bias": -0.7427128697300817, "n": 2775 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 18.60545496989078, "mae": 13.149199163745461, "bias": -1.036548577224781, "n": 2763 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 19.847247136237662, "mae": 14.102925592708381, "bias": -1.1082697598335105, "n": 2762 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 21.906443657938752, "mae": 15.660583108533796, "bias": -1.204626230093149, "n": 2756 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 24.193309830537427, "mae": 16.806807258250526, "bias": -6.106809680700389, "n": 13845 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 23.235345186696435, "mae": 16.126669899115388, "bias": -5.920232478073738, "n": 2789 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 23.282402740581542, "mae": 16.17123186541033, "bias": -6.096268354536177, "n": 2775 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 23.432249225321286, "mae": 16.32742821510141, "bias": -6.275428691895768, "n": 2763 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 24.524643243799694, "mae": 17.097840736604617, "bias": -6.097617865471975, "n": 2762 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 26.362858750997198, "mae": 18.32397512427608, "bias": -6.146399471687129, "n": 2756 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 33.985972294387516, "mae": 23.882001183187114, "bias": -0.574511960113294, "n": 13845 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 28.662515437390933, "mae": 19.43305013991035, "bias": -0.30624828974633883, "n": 2789 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 33.451594350698656, "mae": 23.314204447978252, "bias": -0.7100237487243103, "n": 2775 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 35.28595534870219, "mae": 24.982897747093638, "bias": -0.7894138497716052, "n": 2763 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 35.53183124522454, "mae": 25.49643422761402, "bias": -0.608565831167123, "n": 2762 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 36.48084505458924, "mae": 26.234294044262093, "bias": -0.45996604221825677, "n": 2756 } ], "stations": 38 }, { "id": "cams_benchmark_2026_ytd_20260620", "source": "TROPOMI", "dates": [ "2026-01-21", "2026-06-20" ], "initializations": 151, "rows": [ { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 12.031761524574499, "mae": 8.040300427188482, "bias": -1.3440652267046003, "n": 30510545 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 9.647361739201484, "mae": 6.36753704809151, "bias": -0.9029806970115601, "n": 6163138 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 10.73565738517067, "mae": 7.282337347334579, "bias": -1.3308111476961386, "n": 6146729 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 11.663277049867984, "mae": 7.961827470094391, "bias": -1.4395544796453308, "n": 6106904 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 12.836737394041938, "mae": 8.730638093889445, "bias": -1.477071296946935, "n": 6066919 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 14.71106221932598, "mae": 9.908516818595652, "bias": -1.5779937520405494, "n": 6026855 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 17.90950284015663, "mae": 12.936773008355958, "bias": -8.403936760726046, "n": 30510545 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 16.998481756079936, "mae": 12.367511840462983, "bias": -8.16408658532924, "n": 6163138 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 17.267693227129968, "mae": 12.564899787588427, "bias": -8.38061641057243, "n": 6146729 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 17.627299102822303, "mae": 12.801014625046525, "bias": -8.467981804010048, "n": 6106904 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 18.272609772993313, "mae": 13.182593418043552, "bias": -8.502680506940598, "n": 6066919 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 19.319263796678825, "mae": 13.788283447237472, "bias": -8.508698923051606, "n": 6026855 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 26.599508388092595, "mae": 16.901405324603132, "bias": 0.4639124003758245, "n": 30510545 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 19.47360049966872, "mae": 11.841429020222897, "bias": 0.2788905852114556, "n": 6163138 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 25.138578561018157, "mae": 15.951479585438177, "bias": 0.3604014673323267, "n": 6146729 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 27.64716422661828, "mae": 17.90829423968506, "bias": 0.45987452148646746, "n": 6106904 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 29.077923825895937, "mae": 19.01440694946239, "bias": 0.5649280384090454, "n": 6066919 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 30.395129463921847, "mae": 19.89731026697159, "bias": 0.6610921697387979, "n": 6026855 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 10.627502602563998, "mae": 6.795391141224763, "bias": -0.8025875156324109, "n": 20637595 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 8.719416546329361, "mae": 5.440350399200751, "bias": -0.5106573009566464, "n": 4171001 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 9.531709847072843, "mae": 6.187047285227017, "bias": -0.8105623697951696, "n": 4158181 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 10.262267288007974, "mae": 6.729680188042523, "bias": -0.8592838661820446, "n": 4130524 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 11.252572769339746, "mae": 7.3448857764824504, "bias": -0.8868823742329381, "n": 4102813 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 12.931860900039876, "mae": 8.316449602001354, "bias": -0.9509157602826462, "n": 4075075 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 16.549340342282484, "mae": 11.923794305100584, "bias": -8.663431538714162, "n": 20637595 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 15.792407694714335, "mae": 11.47611379871557, "bias": -8.496904435878688, "n": 4171001 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 16.035602620824136, "mae": 11.647648975272347, "bias": -8.64671234843649, "n": 4158181 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 16.336477878573, "mae": 11.834599196223625, "bias": -8.709447999543688, "n": 4130524 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 16.851199291733455, "mae": 12.116949937623012, "bias": -8.735041596191286, "n": 4102813 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 17.69077416460289, "mae": 12.559728431119252, "bias": -8.73219871416411, "n": 4075075 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 24.228044052408023, "mae": 14.421230551585555, "bias": 0.2923465859985803, "n": 20637595 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 18.23857434297512, "mae": 10.298057260608475, "bias": 0.2759760669510579, "n": 4171001 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 23.161375065063297, "mae": 13.722489715245539, "bias": 0.2763173031499963, "n": 4158181 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 25.200805945294267, "mae": 15.295428498871432, "bias": 0.29093283229055666, "n": 4130524 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 26.283606387003807, "mae": 16.12049999191185, "bias": 0.3065699603371243, "n": 4102813 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 27.306489979980498, "mae": 16.757524066765498, "bias": 0.3125714432157432, "n": 4075075 } ], "stations": null }, { "id": "omps_benchmark_2026_ytd_20260620", "source": "OMPS", "dates": [ "2026-01-21", "2026-06-20" ], "initializations": 151, "rows": [ { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 20.189196644558155, "mae": 13.997610986505379, "bias": 4.660952580179164, "n": 29465908 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 19.967765254534775, "mae": 13.727326735518963, "bias": 5.08173788647698, "n": 5895374 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 19.88435131191461, "mae": 13.74256576667021, "bias": 4.669691133245229, "n": 5894629 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 19.985923076397537, "mae": 13.883687585628708, "bias": 4.568627820994668, "n": 5893566 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 20.222169732899822, "mae": 14.103648686886157, "bias": 4.538138614528466, "n": 5892059 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 20.870237720532906, "mae": 14.531279740820928, "bias": 4.446285690094885, "n": 5890280 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 24.19700981692424, "mae": 15.87396556262666, "bias": -2.925510973072572, "n": 29465908 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 23.98916348660011, "mae": 15.72218621484701, "bias": -2.67800381989944, "n": 5895374 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 24.025294662772612, "mae": 15.757507124154245, "bias": -2.8851335282890123, "n": 5894629 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 24.09194852027578, "mae": 15.81740091708155, "bias": -2.9834463437486627, "n": 5893566 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 24.275988881937735, "mae": 15.929168949396635, "bias": -3.02594022685566, "n": 5892059 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 24.59781497293054, "mae": 16.143796736915405, "bias": -3.0552121541994506, "n": 5890280 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 29.810859603348657, "mae": 20.058257860123938, "bias": 6.432103368383861, "n": 29465908 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 26.551997284520723, "mae": 17.730243563365025, "bias": 6.230005105705065, "n": 5895374 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 28.76423720313376, "mae": 19.38214146515373, "bias": 6.321274178935104, "n": 5894629 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 29.993430763343117, "mae": 20.29429811383192, "bias": 6.419350418422908, "n": 5893566 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 31.19316311661542, "mae": 21.09774442554911, "bias": 6.534365562729769, "n": 5892059 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "unweighted", "rmse": 32.227318978642614, "mae": 21.788928605628467, "bias": 6.6557544116529215, "n": 5890280 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 18.566915018121282, "mae": 12.596981031693229, "bias": 5.338582152292933, "n": 20352353 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 18.552852080580394, "mae": 12.493020746986703, "bias": 5.637053505167803, "n": 4071100 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 18.413628348948706, "mae": 12.451029602496856, "bias": 5.336783570958214, "n": 4071074 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 18.409637568892315, "mae": 12.509737602113283, "bias": 5.28188756394628, "n": 4070806 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 18.509353407675928, "mae": 12.628614077663759, "bias": 5.250594469349758, "n": 4070099 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 18.94402515354917, "mae": 12.902640914023124, "bias": 5.186497632590241, "n": 4069272 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 21.915827574411097, "mae": 13.7946550416399, "bias": -2.754764595358867, "n": 20352353 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 21.765477810118036, "mae": 13.684093412471293, "bias": -2.542446512367023, "n": 4071100 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 21.79051760138541, "mae": 13.71175706623341, "bias": -2.7065841807084037, "n": 4071074 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 21.837911225302598, "mae": 13.759765677921044, "bias": -2.796854270224723, "n": 4070806 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 21.973701455553506, "mae": 13.833993590247033, "bias": -2.848955930995561, "n": 4070099 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 22.208625157484406, "mae": 13.983756988551033, "bias": -2.8790637756779094, "n": 4069272 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 27.16446745766556, "mae": 17.580843219602706, "bias": 6.438631164551533, "n": 20352353 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 24.561170037247685, "mae": 15.81316519527648, "bias": 6.42455299512325, "n": 4071100 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 26.373073468611718, "mae": 17.108797527464343, "bias": 6.428177053959002, "n": 4071074 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 27.323786741140932, "mae": 17.773317650567083, "bias": 6.4333968695369, "n": 4070806 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 28.266266305254174, "mae": 18.34967299195421, "bias": 6.446356925176896, "n": 4070099 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "area_weighted", "rmse": 29.07307709154115, "mae": 18.860036942906703, "bias": 6.46068333437341, "n": 4069272 } ], "stations": null }, { "id": "woudc_benchmark_2026_ytd_20260620", "source": "WOUDC", "dates": [ "2026-01-21", "2026-06-20" ], "initializations": 151, "rows": [ { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 19.763022727813315, "mae": 13.889538857457918, "bias": 2.433029525763017, "n": 22217 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 18.33785013793879, "mae": 12.641086629734005, "bias": 3.1032076036052603, "n": 4456 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 18.651572740981635, "mae": 12.994924807350154, "bias": 2.5036867903891054, "n": 4447 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 19.250008199469146, "mae": 13.568466148720132, "bias": 2.3081379280434, "n": 4440 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 20.374100624071996, "mae": 14.486079818199658, "bias": 2.2650584207780997, "n": 4439 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 21.987126095685813, "mae": 15.76529292952786, "bias": 1.9819846685467606, "n": 4435 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 24.098806162643324, "mae": 17.180139935423888, "bias": -6.198117585617239, "n": 22217 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 23.285018129327472, "mae": 16.520728588960328, "bias": -6.073811806725001, "n": 4456 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 23.372850404578646, "mae": 16.667996405911815, "bias": -6.265455605824503, "n": 4447 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 23.62536043729899, "mae": 16.867999913670996, "bias": -6.291834925746058, "n": 4440 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 24.277247260076436, "mae": 17.40311190404718, "bias": -6.1694228861293805, "n": 4439 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 25.846299863424388, "mae": 18.445521753562748, "bias": -6.190389323100162, "n": 4435 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 34.31334107462312, "mae": 24.462052035826442, "bias": 4.032618012904542, "n": 22217 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 29.162723885130386, "mae": 19.999052448375433, "bias": 3.845211570095973, "n": 4456 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 33.817370948984944, "mae": 23.86128448630441, "bias": 3.791424877594797, "n": 4447 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 35.61552346386271, "mae": 25.603401562115092, "bias": 3.8850494453498907, "n": 4440 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 35.857652229037804, "mae": 26.085630165507435, "bias": 4.229623868890269, "n": 4439 }, { "source": "WOUDC", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "station_pairs", "rmse": 36.60806220493062, "mae": 26.780898538651837, "bias": 4.413308977301252, "n": 4435 } ], "stations": 45 } ], "regional": { "rows": [ { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 24.269706351598632, "mae": 19.416850392547722, "bias": -1.1907722702305854, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 64.012132842853, "mae": 61.78785285251045, "bias": 43.96094135661701, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 26.19403015609161, "mae": 21.37718069223257, "bias": 14.107832552172761, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 47.54225037402085, "mae": 39.37771570807936, "bias": 10.073124751835076, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 20.623533502820397, "mae": 16.331400964310756, "bias": 10.407708849784655, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 24.36152674739161, "mae": 19.411150875999812, "bias": 4.287908223470051, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 62.44501884993868, "mae": 57.20736810593378, "bias": 43.943359375, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 23.267326868353013, "mae": 18.54008297874814, "bias": 9.565642235165551, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 47.884026106803084, "mae": 40.094480009533115, "bias": 15.550340082077753, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 23.72670673196185, "mae": 19.540677737281435, "bias": 16.922248665945872, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 33.20092163714907, "mae": 26.49014189738087, "bias": 0.015975890159618384, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 60.168722849515554, "mae": 54.19358303996152, "bias": 49.58785763228895, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 34.112976495028796, "mae": 27.01601521955695, "bias": 8.518432831901395, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 53.62041293347837, "mae": 44.745331738494166, "bias": 20.390441692640078, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 27.83232932729651, "mae": 22.094674213767394, "bias": 12.607564297786993, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 23.389844352250666, "mae": 18.521196923151688, "bias": -7.793186476952731, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 54.56386803952853, "mae": 49.10818103836149, "bias": 41.52656606132532, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 23.019013845717836, "mae": 18.162531388402247, "bias": 0.6727459550624918, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 46.74801175125857, "mae": 37.886582859750746, "bias": 12.498604595807352, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 15.921945424227218, "mae": 12.546567710227732, "bias": 4.670100002245327, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 20.952919911681963, "mae": 16.585595215752434, "bias": -2.782892895076232, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 49.79144071126968, "mae": 44.321936065998166, "bias": 39.86073979105294, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 21.425439708914965, "mae": 17.07043714449353, "bias": 4.175071518625437, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 42.09379577427058, "mae": 34.38072057770969, "bias": 15.562584447612478, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 17.202896163585784, "mae": 13.826858652594316, "bias": 8.87378184814925, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 21.964234915560745, "mae": 17.599485124271848, "bias": -10.257055748341314, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 43.7822366745711, "mae": 38.41292344365892, "bias": 32.37610148568447, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 20.25310806748267, "mae": 16.026597422565104, "bias": -3.299325303118824, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 38.921472276517676, "mae": 31.665296027455547, "bias": 8.054378389916433, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 14.065535497047513, "mae": 11.138520595555544, "bias": 1.3933070921544364, "n": 18 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 22.93775793995194, "mae": 18.097577266483516, "bias": -1.6082296853537112, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 64.012132842853, "mae": 61.78785285251045, "bias": 43.96094135661701, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "GFS", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 25.42451202759732, "mae": 20.27167803753863, "bias": 12.934903255923762, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 35.06248859007625, "mae": 29.21475222409427, "bias": 5.672377947573259, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 15.56902930119801, "mae": 12.39552958170573, "bias": 8.75248076610076, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 23.397963029176648, "mae": 18.662536798833493, "bias": -2.4514520945566494, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 64.012132842853, "mae": 61.78785285251045, "bias": 43.96094135661701, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "GFS", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 25.340983587438178, "mae": 20.653320305792843, "bias": 14.99547375130566, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 49.115982035062025, "mae": 43.478988271859976, "bias": 8.966435370253118, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 17.052151707295575, "mae": 14.008999906546903, "bias": 9.550482121841373, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 22.75333470145547, "mae": 18.92534085116544, "bias": -2.415901100242532, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 64.012132842853, "mae": 61.78785285251045, "bias": 43.96094135661701, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "GFS", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 26.213931200381733, "mae": 20.9112938558837, "bias": 15.255339324168668, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 51.94883309413935, "mae": 45.07956576951694, "bias": 10.385130896935094, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 19.544954953862263, "mae": 15.308981504335511, "bias": 12.53877992734804, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 25.55928547381592, "mae": 21.018494282816793, "bias": -0.5878959012992228, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 64.012132842853, "mae": 61.78785285251045, "bias": 43.96094135661701, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "GFS", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 26.967579347527916, "mae": 22.865849794939763, "bias": 16.699825848589885, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 50.840382587140766, "mae": 42.631384527744395, "bias": 10.951220300695397, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 23.51407400634062, "mae": 19.317096374288152, "bias": 13.032261026123939, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 25.89897802905909, "mae": 20.380302763439364, "bias": 1.109617430299192, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 64.012132842853, "mae": 61.78785285251045, "bias": 43.96094135661701, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "GFS", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 26.323784802697322, "mae": 22.18376146700793, "bias": 10.653620580875828, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 47.2961759681059, "mae": 36.48388774718121, "bias": 14.390459243718519, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 24.51578457642198, "mae": 20.626397454677488, "bias": 8.164540407509156, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 23.02436837476865, "mae": 18.567093694777718, "bias": 3.67632816859654, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 62.44501884993868, "mae": 57.20736810593378, "bias": 43.943359375, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "GFS", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 23.649437157546384, "mae": 18.71136946905227, "bias": 10.591234697614398, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 39.45564086427648, "mae": 31.292548552013578, "bias": 3.9013810657319574, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 22.469970977286387, "mae": 17.892406572614398, "bias": 16.154756600516187, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 22.96875919622307, "mae": 18.78501477922712, "bias": 4.521522521972655, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 62.44501884993868, "mae": 57.20736810593378, "bias": 43.943359375, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "GFS", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 24.144408870000902, "mae": 19.155006263369607, "bias": 11.678183346702939, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 48.36052198207928, "mae": 38.466544523693265, "bias": 0.8958252679734002, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 25.068687359126322, "mae": 20.56855163574219, "bias": 18.740415300641743, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 22.540979548919353, "mae": 17.89150717599051, "bias": 4.159121631440662, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 62.44501884993868, "mae": 57.20736810593378, "bias": 43.943359375, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "GFS", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 22.623950880478322, "mae": 18.40287134079706, "bias": 10.317828151157924, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 52.75876931660248, "mae": 45.20899411156064, "bias": 14.947025989350816, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 23.038419035835197, "mae": 19.629361906505768, "bias": 17.256918407621836, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 25.678658368357056, "mae": 20.902895028250562, "bias": 6.458039129348029, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 62.44501884993868, "mae": 57.20736810593378, "bias": 43.943359375, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "GFS", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 23.363436169755452, "mae": 18.71647179013207, "bias": 9.967692347935268, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 48.3541904805959, "mae": 43.765344964890254, "bias": 26.455690947033112, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 24.74641579148362, "mae": 21.1439940679641, "bias": 18.698526654924667, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 26.31945580711193, "mae": 20.909243701753162, "bias": 2.6245296659923727, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 62.44501884993868, "mae": 57.20736810593378, "bias": 43.943359375, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "GFS", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 21.403087914171333, "mae": 17.714696030389696, "bias": 5.273272632417225, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 46.2427922226796, "mae": 41.73896789550781, "bias": 31.551777140299475, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 22.461399690998604, "mae": 18.469074503580728, "bias": 13.760626366024926, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 32.84357565728023, "mae": 26.065147687133486, "bias": 0.7264818880742586, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 60.168722849515554, "mae": 54.19358303996152, "bias": 49.58785763228895, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 33.05876609753454, "mae": 26.31107233961744, "bias": 5.862171462602674, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 40.366479888137185, "mae": 32.350039589532834, "bias": 8.285172201451841, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 27.13487351667464, "mae": 21.596850746596996, "bias": 11.422647635378347, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 33.04054722600979, "mae": 26.289185063075937, "bias": 0.43292432828304134, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 60.168722849515554, "mae": 54.19358303996152, "bias": 49.58785763228895, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 33.75249539510559, "mae": 26.79844468173115, "bias": 8.118137534784958, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 51.79085853731551, "mae": 43.767247672866375, "bias": 12.242863390287757, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 27.551031615112265, "mae": 21.874525187865597, "bias": 11.90974412718194, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 33.031711846997, "mae": 26.322684703944898, "bias": -0.20444147170567586, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 60.168722849515554, "mae": 54.19358303996152, "bias": 49.58785763228895, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 34.371879875936, "mae": 27.28648262086281, "bias": 9.184402364593828, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 57.30150649830313, "mae": 49.23367078891385, "bias": 19.750276475074184, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 27.408551803370525, "mae": 21.820568525557448, "bias": 12.341709930928154, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 33.3619099240058, "mae": 26.662459914590077, "bias": -0.3996186854986572, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 60.168722849515554, "mae": 54.19358303996152, "bias": 49.58785763228895, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 34.417711788291925, "mae": 27.18873610191146, "bias": 9.619547817191593, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 57.541128454364554, "mae": 49.248386460985046, "bias": 28.15799372224114, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 27.316905922455906, "mae": 21.675842919167877, "bias": 12.787877662943421, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 33.59986648090504, "mae": 27.111232118159943, "bias": -0.47546660835487753, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 60.168722849515554, "mae": 54.19358303996152, "bias": 49.58785763228895, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 34.56569188207052, "mae": 27.495340353661916, "bias": 9.807904980333923, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 57.46717979068453, "mae": 49.12731418017268, "bias": 33.51590267414546, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 29.307638509353524, "mae": 23.505583689649058, "bias": 14.575842132503105, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 22.121712204497452, "mae": 17.48229439448132, "bias": -7.090802609579928, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 54.56386803952852, "mae": 49.10818103836149, "bias": 41.52656606132532, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 21.57272210032455, "mae": 17.11826036264802, "bias": -1.9706352017882451, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 29.101018676921964, "mae": 22.84881734969454, "bias": 0.39790102313226655, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 12.966639353242003, "mae": 10.289436002054975, "bias": 3.501644488476085, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 22.557630475185956, "mae": 17.890353216730695, "bias": -7.385888480433276, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 54.56386803952852, "mae": 49.10818103836149, "bias": 41.52656606132532, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 22.396559969718393, "mae": 17.7061055658227, "bias": 0.2846551266777748, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 43.304947538692296, "mae": 35.9297192845239, "bias": 4.339050787350022, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 14.128735684751119, "mae": 11.318511682639027, "bias": 3.9888900041910413, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 22.860201960919984, "mae": 18.160921745751875, "bias": -8.036412188058508, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 54.56386803952852, "mae": 49.10818103836149, "bias": 41.52656606132532, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 22.76857250056239, "mae": 18.04659238070565, "bias": 1.3414726011291809, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 50.4986523357498, "mae": 42.259057811759384, "bias": 11.88531927860159, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 14.97368315182768, "mae": 12.050419592580313, "bias": 4.414282033968056, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 23.972959977599995, "mae": 18.95138746208048, "bias": -8.198803124554692, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 54.56386803952852, "mae": 49.10818103836149, "bias": 41.52656606132532, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 23.33027686739805, "mae": 18.63400611243817, "bias": 1.7680826758434713, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 51.45564566346045, "mae": 43.60859305350265, "bias": 20.260900319781122, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 16.455376852959784, "mae": 13.202772140082923, "bias": 4.838447998461005, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 25.109036603639385, "mae": 20.12102779671407, "bias": -8.254025982137255, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 54.56386803952852, "mae": 49.10818103836149, "bias": 41.52656606132532, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 24.526272262111533, "mae": 19.30769252039669, "bias": 1.9401545734502779, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 53.02290600567401, "mae": 44.78672679927323, "bias": 25.609851570171767, "n": 24 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 19.65192111731501, "mae": 15.871699133781414, "bias": 6.6072354861304525, "n": 24 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 19.946565426496353, "mae": 15.752853535581519, "bias": -2.9361580730030177, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 49.79144071126968, "mae": 44.321936065998166, "bias": 39.860739791052936, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 19.678362694552092, "mae": 15.732618125747214, "bias": 2.3173734582030807, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 30.281972748277767, "mae": 24.355894046457323, "bias": 7.231912795017304, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 14.279679654888728, "mae": 11.578871386523872, "bias": 7.670895089048126, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 20.13999115635872, "mae": 15.985890025412298, "bias": -3.2888675541657526, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 49.79144071126968, "mae": 44.321936065998166, "bias": 39.860739791052936, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 20.622692885437377, "mae": 16.584671510411205, "bias": 3.1236411311178975, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 40.20567064982404, "mae": 33.266659363146566, "bias": 9.67554680575061, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 15.420212494246762, "mae": 12.547042188032682, "bias": 8.113164507959205, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 20.595935816426817, "mae": 16.38271540532417, "bias": -3.1934813971297378, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 49.79144071126968, "mae": 44.321936065998166, "bias": 39.860739791052936, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 21.486822435466586, "mae": 17.289709166648446, "bias": 4.1962537232998045, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 45.56087667991986, "mae": 37.40914451378581, "bias": 14.005712353533372, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 16.75076132338344, "mae": 13.61780677239874, "bias": 8.394623034042604, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 21.296823206045676, "mae": 16.975261881455545, "bias": -2.5087256406145615, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 49.79144071126968, "mae": 44.321936065998166, "bias": 39.860739791052936, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 22.08308295251746, "mae": 17.4870887324477, "bias": 4.810158402048941, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 45.260285207087776, "mae": 37.98537350096269, "bias": 20.961041634562484, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 18.194109088137623, "mae": 14.706940895191886, "bias": 9.431743193182449, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 22.39064617364856, "mae": 17.831255230988635, "bias": -1.987231810468091, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 49.79144071126968, "mae": 44.321936065998166, "bias": 39.860739791052936, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 22.834567981970242, "mae": 18.25809818721308, "bias": 6.427930878457463, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 46.09698932282179, "mae": 38.88653146419602, "bias": 25.938708649198603, "n": 18 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 20.41962756719944, "mae": 16.68363202082439, "bias": 10.758483416513858, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 21.155014148781188, "mae": 17.014073864319027, "bias": -10.421459633634278, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 43.7822366745711, "mae": 38.41292344365892, "bias": 32.37610148568447, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 19.121546160265147, "mae": 15.183134477121833, "bias": -5.165163233330437, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 27.92649716846151, "mae": 22.350606991197097, "bias": -0.319244663375539, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 11.067521323983415, "mae": 8.906926789826807, "bias": 0.1790796365331538, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 21.36736923143083, "mae": 17.269887572306516, "bias": -10.763232481218838, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 43.7822366745711, "mae": 38.41292344365892, "bias": 32.37610148568447, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 19.744558723061367, "mae": 15.751740065513319, "bias": -4.355746632278367, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 37.752172803783516, "mae": 31.392583955852192, "bias": 2.095727535871173, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 12.399165237954563, "mae": 10.02472989052882, "bias": 0.6384442524754638, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 21.71184519376874, "mae": 17.43914903706147, "bias": -10.664208358022815, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 43.7822366745711, "mae": 38.41292344365892, "bias": 32.37610148568447, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 20.301261578502242, "mae": 16.11743496458316, "bias": -3.26464343201319, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 42.611627547134134, "mae": 35.048346492217284, "bias": 6.493960627449344, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 13.899243432389891, "mae": 11.232346846885212, "bias": 0.9255731759816379, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 22.254129888612013, "mae": 17.88743896493888, "bias": -9.980349876522103, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 43.7822366745711, "mae": 38.41292344365892, "bias": 32.37610148568447, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 20.741251868228872, "mae": 16.322026231967428, "bias": -2.684326207948996, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 41.41588675971812, "mae": 34.529786772745545, "bias": 13.51017022737116, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 15.033197480733273, "mae": 11.958168169440032, "bias": 1.9420984649500324, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 23.038393730182367, "mae": 18.38687618273334, "bias": -9.456028392308532, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 43.7822366745711, "mae": 38.41292344365892, "bias": 32.37610148568447, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 21.112182395776493, "mae": 16.75865137363979, "bias": -1.026747010023128, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 41.777726439896846, "mae": 35.005155925265655, "bias": 18.491278222266025, "n": 18 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 16.96839446542595, "mae": 13.570431281096853, "bias": 3.2813399308318933, "n": 18 } ], "events": [ { "region_id": "-55_-110", "center_lat": "-55", "center_lon": "-110", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "SH", "peak_date": "2025-02-15", "year": "2025", "quarter": "1", "run_start": "2025-02-13", "run_end": "2025-02-16", "run_days": "4", "start": "2025-02-12", "end": "2025-02-18", "strength": "0.1491307907473286", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "239.5092985978372", "TROPOMI_normal": "288.23019475545885", "TROPOMI_deficit": "48.72089615762167", "OMPS_mean": "243.80706278756168", "OMPS_normal": "286.53882422387846", "OMPS_deficit": "42.73176143631679", "event_id": "2025_Q1_SH_2", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "+70_-070", "center_lat": "70", "center_lon": "-70", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2025-02-19", "year": "2025", "quarter": "1", "run_start": "2025-02-19", "run_end": "2025-02-21", "run_days": "3", "start": "2025-02-16", "end": "2025-02-22", "strength": "0.4072155440402116", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "250.008755581062", "TROPOMI_normal": "421.7532242411251", "TROPOMI_deficit": "171.74446866006312", "OMPS_mean": "264.29851764671736", "OMPS_normal": "449.61165664284187", "OMPS_deficit": "185.3131389961245", "event_id": "2025_Q1_NH_1", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "+60_+090", "center_lat": "60", "center_lon": "90", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2025-02-25", "year": "2025", "quarter": "1", "run_start": "2025-02-23", "run_end": "2025-03-03", "run_days": "9", "start": "2025-02-22", "end": "2025-02-28", "strength": "0.31048886053370894", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "274.44194275777136", "TROPOMI_normal": "398.02394341330046", "TROPOMI_deficit": "123.5820006555291", "OMPS_mean": "265.41348147056334", "OMPS_normal": "386.5014169925136", "OMPS_deficit": "121.08793552195027", "event_id": "2025_Q1_NH_3", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "-45_-030", "center_lat": "-45", "center_lon": "-30", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "SH", "peak_date": "2025-03-08", "year": "2025", "quarter": "1", "run_start": "2025-03-06", "run_end": "2025-03-08", "run_days": "3", "start": "2025-03-05", "end": "2025-03-11", "strength": "0.11934912942664894", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "242.35851436252577", "TROPOMI_normal": "279.0120651770394", "TROPOMI_deficit": "36.653550814513636", "OMPS_mean": "244.43496529957037", "OMPS_normal": "277.56171425848936", "OMPS_deficit": "33.126748958918995", "event_id": "2025_Q1_SH_3", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "+60_+010", "center_lat": "60", "center_lon": "10", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2025-03-18", "year": "2025", "quarter": "1", "run_start": "2025-03-17", "run_end": "2025-03-27", "run_days": "11", "start": "2025-03-15", "end": "2025-03-21", "strength": "0.3176033858678786", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "259.30437630088255", "TROPOMI_normal": "379.9907135100141", "TROPOMI_deficit": "120.68633720913152", "OMPS_mean": "262.303554646114", "OMPS_normal": "385.5668652446183", "OMPS_deficit": "123.26331059850435", "event_id": "2025_Q1_NH_2", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "-55_-070", "center_lat": "-55", "center_lon": "-70", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "SH", "peak_date": "2025-03-23", "year": "2025", "quarter": "1", "run_start": "2025-03-23", "run_end": "2025-03-24", "run_days": "2", "start": "2025-03-20", "end": "2025-03-26", "strength": "0.15886351159460788", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "232.9364797483666", "TROPOMI_normal": "285.6357833692087", "TROPOMI_deficit": "52.6993036208421", "OMPS_mean": "238.64690925587757", "OMPS_normal": "283.7196014505316", "OMPS_deficit": "45.07269219465405", "event_id": "2025_Q1_SH_1", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "+60_+010", "center_lat": "60", "center_lon": "10", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2025-04-01", "year": "2025", "quarter": "2", "run_start": "2025-03-31", "run_end": "2025-04-02", "run_days": "3", "start": "2025-03-29", "end": "2025-04-04", "strength": "0.2193548572912952", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "305.9289265236132", "TROPOMI_normal": "394.405791194441", "TROPOMI_deficit": "88.47686467082781", "OMPS_mean": "304.869051627624", "OMPS_normal": "390.5347448519063", "OMPS_deficit": "85.66569322428228", "event_id": "2025_Q2_NH_1", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "+70_-090", "center_lat": "70", "center_lon": "-90", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2025-04-08", "year": "2025", "quarter": "2", "run_start": "2025-04-07", "run_end": "2025-04-08", "run_days": "2", "start": "2025-04-05", "end": "2025-04-11", "strength": "0.1641759179211891", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "353.76046760595335", "TROPOMI_normal": "432.79604194470187", "TROPOMI_deficit": "79.03557433874852", "OMPS_mean": "363.7709031405401", "OMPS_normal": "435.22424268488555", "OMPS_deficit": "71.45333954434545", "event_id": "2025_Q2_NH_2", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "+40_-050", "center_lat": "40", "center_lon": "-50", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2025-04-12", "year": "2025", "quarter": "2", "run_start": "2025-04-08", "run_end": "2025-04-13", "run_days": "6", "start": "2025-04-09", "end": "2025-04-15", "strength": "0.16181251079511888", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "303.3835314686387", "TROPOMI_normal": "361.9518727921285", "TROPOMI_deficit": "58.56834132348979", "OMPS_mean": "296.2627010108221", "OMPS_normal": "357.43583702002076", "OMPS_deficit": "61.17313600919863", "event_id": "2025_Q2_NH_3", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "-55_+090", "center_lat": "-55", "center_lon": "90", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "SH", "peak_date": "2025-05-23", "year": "2025", "quarter": "2", "run_start": "2025-05-22", "run_end": "2025-05-24", "run_days": "3", "start": "2025-05-20", "end": "2025-05-26", "strength": "0.2039407565311928", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "231.94762162267273", "TROPOMI_normal": "313.1289901091972", "TROPOMI_deficit": "81.18136848652449", "OMPS_mean": "241.061008273035", "OMPS_normal": "302.81792498585656", "OMPS_deficit": "61.75691671282158", "event_id": "2025_Q2_SH_2", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "-45_-150", "center_lat": "-45", "center_lon": "-150", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "SH", "peak_date": "2025-06-07", "year": "2025", "quarter": "2", "run_start": "2025-06-05", "run_end": "2025-06-08", "run_days": "4", "start": "2025-06-04", "end": "2025-06-10", "strength": "0.19145702702741804", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "256.1605604687248", "TROPOMI_normal": "316.8174964491483", "TROPOMI_deficit": "60.6569359804235", "OMPS_mean": "249.36782939826008", "OMPS_normal": "309.89251413265964", "OMPS_deficit": "60.52468473439956", "event_id": "2025_Q2_SH_3", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "-45_-030", "center_lat": "-45", "center_lon": "-30", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "SH", "peak_date": "2025-06-15", "year": "2025", "quarter": "2", "run_start": "2025-06-14", "run_end": "2025-06-18", "run_days": "5", "start": "2025-06-12", "end": "2025-06-18", "strength": "0.2077508726547243", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "246.58326645786525", "TROPOMI_normal": "311.24460469162506", "TROPOMI_deficit": "64.6613382337598", "OMPS_mean": "234.86778536715855", "OMPS_normal": "304.5978783789358", "OMPS_deficit": "69.73009301177723", "event_id": "2025_Q2_SH_1", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "+60_-170", "center_lat": "60", "center_lon": "-170", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2025-07-26", "year": "2025", "quarter": "3", "run_start": "2025-07-24", "run_end": "2025-07-31", "run_days": "8", "start": "2025-07-23", "end": "2025-07-29", "strength": "0.16064550536744945", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "278.04186189671935", "TROPOMI_normal": "335.9073463625455", "TROPOMI_deficit": "57.86548446582617", "OMPS_mean": "276.49484446240695", "OMPS_normal": "329.41366994579545", "OMPS_deficit": "52.9188254833885", "event_id": "2025_Q3_NH_2", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "+70_-010", "center_lat": "70", "center_lon": "-10", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2025-08-26", "year": "2025", "quarter": "3", "run_start": "2025-08-21", "run_end": "2025-08-27", "run_days": "7", "start": "2025-08-23", "end": "2025-08-29", "strength": "0.1552686039589783", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "261.5230701384944", "TROPOMI_normal": "314.44918485286496", "TROPOMI_deficit": "52.926114714370556", "OMPS_mean": "258.1623093632634", "OMPS_normal": "305.61467298739603", "OMPS_deficit": "47.45236362413266", "event_id": "2025_Q3_NH_3", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "-55_-050", "center_lat": "-55", "center_lon": "-50", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "SH", "peak_date": "2025-08-31", "year": "2025", "quarter": "3", "run_start": "2025-08-31", "run_end": "2025-09-06", "run_days": "7", "start": "2025-08-28", "end": "2025-09-03", "strength": "0.2651894419289225", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "227.590552077994", "TROPOMI_normal": "309.7268399020192", "TROPOMI_deficit": "82.1362878240252", "OMPS_mean": "219.22264078351904", "OMPS_normal": "301.93418795654117", "OMPS_deficit": "82.71154717302213", "event_id": "2025_Q3_SH_3", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "+60_-110", "center_lat": "60", "center_lon": "-110", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2025-09-17", "year": "2025", "quarter": "3", "run_start": "2025-09-11", "run_end": "2025-09-21", "run_days": "11", "start": "2025-09-14", "end": "2025-09-20", "strength": "0.16164508494265648", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "256.59614421400187", "TROPOMI_normal": "307.07182677611246", "TROPOMI_deficit": "50.47568256211059", "OMPS_mean": "253.9352362345271", "OMPS_normal": "302.8970566924605", "OMPS_deficit": "48.96182045793341", "event_id": "2025_Q3_NH_1", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "-55_-050", "center_lat": "-55", "center_lon": "-50", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "SH", "peak_date": "2025-09-17", "year": "2025", "quarter": "3", "run_start": "2025-09-16", "run_end": "2025-09-18", "run_days": "3", "start": "2025-09-14", "end": "2025-09-20", "strength": "0.2892546390295479", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "212.7185399523665", "TROPOMI_normal": "299.2893821521684", "TROPOMI_deficit": "86.57084219980189", "OMPS_mean": "203.0644922559455", "OMPS_normal": "291.396186716211", "OMPS_deficit": "88.33169446026548", "event_id": "2025_Q3_SH_1", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "-55_-010", "center_lat": "-55", "center_lon": "-10", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "SH", "peak_date": "2025-09-22", "year": "2025", "quarter": "3", "run_start": "2025-09-18", "run_end": "2025-09-22", "run_days": "5", "start": "2025-09-19", "end": "2025-09-25", "strength": "0.2853603089363116", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "214.84751078428485", "TROPOMI_normal": "300.63752891264716", "TROPOMI_deficit": "85.7900181283623", "OMPS_mean": "199.29980513367673", "OMPS_normal": "295.666651216141", "OMPS_deficit": "96.36684608246429", "event_id": "2025_Q3_SH_2", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "-55_-050", "center_lat": "-55", "center_lon": "-50", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "SH", "peak_date": "2025-10-11", "year": "2025", "quarter": "4", "run_start": "2025-10-10", "run_end": "2025-10-11", "run_days": "2", "start": "2025-10-08", "end": "2025-10-14", "strength": "0.32966786998456854", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "202.69524752383808", "TROPOMI_normal": "302.38032528617106", "TROPOMI_deficit": "99.68507776233298", "OMPS_mean": "195.1796830173378", "OMPS_normal": "295.02542379998306", "OMPS_deficit": "99.84574078264527", "event_id": "2025_Q4_SH_2", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "-55_-070", "center_lat": "-55", "center_lon": "-70", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "SH", "peak_date": "2025-11-08", "year": "2025", "quarter": "4", "run_start": "2025-11-08", "run_end": "2025-11-09", "run_days": "2", "start": "2025-11-05", "end": "2025-11-11", "strength": "0.3482593277374463", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "220.43705593579105", "TROPOMI_normal": "340.8266384122407", "TROPOMI_deficit": "120.38958247644965", "OMPS_mean": "216.0685892267756", "OMPS_normal": "331.52540331215107", "OMPS_deficit": "115.45681408537547", "event_id": "2025_Q4_SH_1", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "-55_-030", "center_lat": "-55", "center_lon": "-30", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "SH", "peak_date": "2025-11-15", "year": "2025", "quarter": "4", "run_start": "2025-11-15", "run_end": "2025-11-16", "run_days": "2", "start": "2025-11-12", "end": "2025-11-18", "strength": "0.24987673491875192", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "241.61099590607265", "TROPOMI_normal": "324.85215994289587", "TROPOMI_deficit": "83.24116403682322", "OMPS_mean": "236.74059828351355", "OMPS_normal": "315.6022607269373", "OMPS_deficit": "78.86166244342374", "event_id": "2025_Q4_SH_3", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "+60_-030", "center_lat": "60", "center_lon": "-30", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2025-11-19", "year": "2025", "quarter": "4", "run_start": "2025-11-14", "run_end": "2025-11-21", "run_days": "8", "start": "2025-11-16", "end": "2025-11-22", "strength": "0.22421282949781007", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "242.75966072062613", "TROPOMI_normal": "312.9204373971287", "TROPOMI_deficit": "70.16077667650256", "OMPS_mean": "232.8551556350104", "OMPS_normal": "303.3563875313163", "OMPS_deficit": "70.50123189630588", "event_id": "2025_Q4_NH_2", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "+50_+090", "center_lat": "50", "center_lon": "90", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2025-11-26", "year": "2025", "quarter": "4", "run_start": "2025-11-23", "run_end": "2025-11-27", "run_days": "5", "start": "2025-11-23", "end": "2025-11-29", "strength": "0.23476737484371565", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "245.0519261573436", "TROPOMI_normal": "320.2319374547006", "TROPOMI_deficit": "75.180011297357", "OMPS_mean": "234.45995155488257", "OMPS_normal": "316.2591300235785", "OMPS_deficit": "81.79917846869594", "event_id": "2025_Q4_NH_1", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "+60_+030", "center_lat": "60", "center_lon": "30", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2025-12-04", "year": "2025", "quarter": "4", "run_start": "2025-12-03", "run_end": "2025-12-05", "run_days": "3", "start": "2025-12-01", "end": "2025-12-07", "strength": "0.2087089284862105", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "244.36368868627227", "TROPOMI_normal": "311.11116559055444", "TROPOMI_deficit": "66.74747690428217", "OMPS_mean": "241.24457142717847", "OMPS_normal": "304.87462845456156", "OMPS_deficit": "63.63005702738309", "event_id": "2025_Q4_NH_3", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "-55_-090", "center_lat": "-55", "center_lon": "-90", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "SH", "peak_date": "2026-01-03", "year": "2026", "quarter": "1", "run_start": "2026-01-01", "run_end": "2026-01-03", "run_days": "3", "start": "2025-12-31", "end": "2026-01-06", "strength": "0.12812597230377762", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "261.51412250101873", "TROPOMI_normal": "299.94484775745065", "TROPOMI_deficit": "38.43072525643191", "OMPS_mean": "254.37364387330135", "OMPS_normal": "292.6418388200164", "OMPS_deficit": "38.268194946715056", "event_id": "2026_Q1_SH_3", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "+60_-090", "center_lat": "60", "center_lon": "-90", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2026-02-02", "year": "2026", "quarter": "1", "run_start": "2026-01-29", "run_end": "2026-02-04", "run_days": "7", "start": "2026-01-30", "end": "2026-02-05", "strength": "0.23780693600257907", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "335.536070260127", "TROPOMI_normal": "440.224512803048", "TROPOMI_deficit": "104.688442542921", "OMPS_mean": "327.0824553745357", "OMPS_normal": "438.63585086165483", "OMPS_deficit": "111.55339548711913", "event_id": "2026_Q1_NH_3", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "+50_+090", "center_lat": "50", "center_lon": "90", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2026-02-07", "year": "2026", "quarter": "1", "run_start": "2026-02-06", "run_end": "2026-02-07", "run_days": "2", "start": "2026-02-04", "end": "2026-02-10", "strength": "0.23939179369928673", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "294.8521266354231", "TROPOMI_normal": "387.65309681506466", "TROPOMI_deficit": "92.80097017964158", "OMPS_mean": "285.66930997817764", "OMPS_normal": "390.1742228456841", "OMPS_deficit": "104.50491286750645", "event_id": "2026_Q1_NH_2", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "+40_-110", "center_lat": "40", "center_lon": "-110", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2026-03-25", "year": "2026", "quarter": "1", "run_start": "2026-03-17", "run_end": "2026-03-29", "run_days": "13", "start": "2026-03-22", "end": "2026-03-28", "strength": "0.2413706179841078", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "265.5309055102669", "TROPOMI_normal": "350.01400130940937", "TROPOMI_deficit": "84.48309579914246", "OMPS_mean": "257.9511879566015", "OMPS_normal": "350.1279207194907", "OMPS_deficit": "92.17673276288923", "event_id": "2026_Q1_NH_1", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "-45_-130", "center_lat": "-45", "center_lon": "-130", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "SH", "peak_date": "2026-03-26", "year": "2026", "quarter": "1", "run_start": "2026-03-24", "run_end": "2026-03-27", "run_days": "4", "start": "2026-03-23", "end": "2026-03-29", "strength": "0.15718791412086855", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "231.554085346425", "TROPOMI_normal": "274.7398728921792", "TROPOMI_deficit": "43.18578754575421", "OMPS_mean": "223.92707473983927", "OMPS_normal": "268.12916804883304", "OMPS_deficit": "44.20209330899377", "event_id": "2026_Q1_SH_1", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "-45_-050", "center_lat": "-45", "center_lon": "-50", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "SH", "peak_date": "2026-03-31", "year": "2026", "quarter": "1", "run_start": "2026-03-29", "run_end": "2026-04-01", "run_days": "4", "start": "2026-03-28", "end": "2026-04-03", "strength": "0.1495672349715189", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "238.77531429309343", "TROPOMI_normal": "280.7691849514956", "TROPOMI_deficit": "41.99387065840219", "OMPS_mean": "233.57950849308628", "OMPS_normal": "277.54038595524634", "OMPS_deficit": "43.960877462160056", "event_id": "2026_Q1_SH_2", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "+60_+150", "center_lat": "60", "center_lon": "150", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2026-04-02", "year": "2026", "quarter": "2", "run_start": "2026-04-02", "run_end": "2026-04-03", "run_days": "2", "start": "2026-03-30", "end": "2026-04-05", "strength": "0.15835580148867331", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "371.3652593731233", "TROPOMI_normal": "441.23782951273506", "TROPOMI_deficit": "69.87257013961175", "OMPS_mean": "366.09996059572126", "OMPS_normal": "440.73085786296133", "OMPS_deficit": "74.63089726724007", "event_id": "2026_Q2_NH_2", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "+50_-170", "center_lat": "50", "center_lon": "-170", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2026-04-13", "year": "2026", "quarter": "2", "run_start": "2026-04-11", "run_end": "2026-04-14", "run_days": "4", "start": "2026-04-10", "end": "2026-04-16", "strength": "0.16228515213765995", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "327.0597798120974", "TROPOMI_normal": "393.08588650073665", "TROPOMI_deficit": "66.02610668863923", "OMPS_mean": "324.4607487735721", "OMPS_normal": "387.3164592958129", "OMPS_deficit": "62.85571052224077", "event_id": "2026_Q2_NH_1", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "-55_-150", "center_lat": "-55", "center_lon": "-150", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "SH", "peak_date": "2026-04-14", "year": "2026", "quarter": "2", "run_start": "2026-04-12", "run_end": "2026-04-15", "run_days": "4", "start": "2026-04-11", "end": "2026-04-17", "strength": "0.19462202913729412", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "235.39151851794833", "TROPOMI_normal": "292.2745928421674", "TROPOMI_deficit": "56.88307432421908", "OMPS_mean": "223.88164747188887", "OMPS_normal": "283.3978249292957", "OMPS_deficit": "59.516177457406855", "event_id": "2026_Q2_SH_3", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "-55_+050", "center_lat": "-55", "center_lon": "50", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "SH", "peak_date": "2026-06-06", "year": "2026", "quarter": "2", "run_start": "2026-06-06", "run_end": "2026-06-07", "run_days": "2", "start": "2026-06-03", "end": "2026-06-09", "strength": "0.22984258105559077", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "236.5873380361657", "TROPOMI_normal": "307.1934804710916", "TROPOMI_deficit": "70.60614243492591", "OMPS_mean": "221.6730564904956", "OMPS_normal": "301.4284582911357", "OMPS_deficit": "79.7554018006401", "event_id": "2026_Q2_SH_1", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "+70_-050", "center_lat": "70", "center_lon": "-50", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2026-06-16", "year": "2026", "quarter": "2", "run_start": "2026-06-14", "run_end": "2026-06-17", "run_days": "4", "start": "2026-06-13", "end": "2026-06-19", "strength": "0.15427837537298197", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "304.0645245052587", "TROPOMI_normal": "359.53263538620985", "TROPOMI_deficit": "55.468110880951144", "OMPS_mean": "301.8949925034654", "OMPS_normal": "358.855603286828", "OMPS_deficit": "56.9606107833626", "event_id": "2026_Q2_NH_3", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "-45_+010", "center_lat": "-45", "center_lon": "10", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "SH", "peak_date": "2026-06-19", "year": "2026", "quarter": "2", "run_start": "2026-06-18", "run_end": "2026-06-21", "run_days": "4", "start": "2026-06-16", "end": "2026-06-22", "strength": "0.22728780020715972", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "241.91807361939237", "TROPOMI_normal": "313.07655513171557", "TROPOMI_deficit": "71.15848151232319", "OMPS_mean": "229.88390009300915", "OMPS_normal": "305.89806823659904", "OMPS_deficit": "76.0141681435899", "event_id": "2026_Q2_SH_2", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "-55_+030", "center_lat": "-55", "center_lon": "30", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "SH", "peak_date": "2026-08-13", "year": "2026", "quarter": "3", "run_start": "2026-08-11", "run_end": "2026-08-15", "run_days": "5", "start": "2026-08-10", "end": "2026-08-16", "strength": "0.2543820263020859", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "259.0960849522709", "TROPOMI_normal": "347.49173717912987", "TROPOMI_deficit": "88.39565222685894", "OMPS_mean": "252.54938835693304", "OMPS_normal": "346.2190430668237", "OMPS_deficit": "93.66965470989066", "event_id": "2026_Q3_SH_3", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "+70_-130", "center_lat": "70", "center_lon": "-130", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2026-08-17", "year": "2026", "quarter": "3", "run_start": "2026-08-16", "run_end": "2026-08-18", "run_days": "3", "start": "2026-08-14", "end": "2026-08-20", "strength": "0.13271382939465978", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "265.6577173700618", "TROPOMI_normal": "306.30918187550543", "TROPOMI_deficit": "40.65146450544364", "OMPS_mean": "259.5143046918311", "OMPS_normal": "302.2231242666231", "OMPS_deficit": "42.70881957479196", "event_id": "2026_Q3_NH_2", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "+70_-050", "center_lat": "70", "center_lon": "-50", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2026-09-05", "year": "2026", "quarter": "3", "run_start": "2026-09-04", "run_end": "2026-09-06", "run_days": "3", "start": "2026-09-02", "end": "2026-09-08", "strength": "0.12871062255026158", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "274.72902230427377", "TROPOMI_normal": "315.31317770498345", "TROPOMI_deficit": "40.584155400709676", "OMPS_mean": "266.90374060864474", "OMPS_normal": "308.320536354369", "OMPS_deficit": "41.416795745724244", "event_id": "2026_Q3_NH_3", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "-55_+070", "center_lat": "-55", "center_lon": "70", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "SH", "peak_date": "2026-09-07", "year": "2026", "quarter": "3", "run_start": "2026-09-06", "run_end": "2026-09-07", "run_days": "2", "start": "2026-09-04", "end": "2026-09-10", "strength": "0.26331776690128883", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "259.23327522638425", "TROPOMI_normal": "351.89293779486127", "TROPOMI_deficit": "92.65966256847702", "OMPS_mean": "247.89935986104535", "OMPS_normal": "343.84177007177493", "OMPS_deficit": "95.94241021072958", "event_id": "2026_Q3_SH_2", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "-55_+110", "center_lat": "-55", "center_lon": "110", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "SH", "peak_date": "2026-09-08", "year": "2026", "quarter": "3", "run_start": "2026-09-08", "run_end": "2026-09-11", "run_days": "4", "start": "2026-09-05", "end": "2026-09-11", "strength": "0.27219156776569087", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "276.4244102452932", "TROPOMI_normal": "379.8038027626227", "TROPOMI_deficit": "103.3793925173295", "OMPS_mean": "258.39838189245484", "OMPS_normal": "370.613899559226", "OMPS_deficit": "112.21551766677118", "event_id": "2026_Q3_SH_1", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" }, { "region_id": "+60_-130", "center_lat": "60", "center_lon": "-130", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2026-09-12", "year": "2026", "quarter": "3", "run_start": "2026-09-11", "run_end": "2026-09-13", "run_days": "3", "start": "2026-09-09", "end": "2026-09-15", "strength": "0.16152426267669903", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "261.91083837924253", "TROPOMI_normal": "312.36543494430833", "TROPOMI_deficit": "50.4545965650658", "OMPS_mean": "256.2453544198502", "OMPS_normal": "305.90795471392477", "OMPS_deficit": "49.66260029407459", "event_id": "2026_Q3_NH_1", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS" } ], "wins": [ { "year": "", "source": "OMPS", "mask_mode": "reference_only", "qc": "all", "scope": "all", "baseline": "CAMS", "n_events": "42", "model_wins": "31", "ties": "0", "mean_delta_rmse": "-4.674920069099828", "hemisphere": "" }, { "year": "", "source": "OMPS", "mask_mode": "reference_only", "qc": "all", "scope": "all", "baseline": "GFS", "n_events": "42", "model_wins": "34", "ties": "0", "mean_delta_rmse": "-5.398602758130958", "hemisphere": "" }, { "year": "", "source": "TROPOMI", "mask_mode": "reference_only", "qc": "all", "scope": "all", "baseline": "CAMS", "n_events": "42", "model_wins": "37", "ties": "0", "mean_delta_rmse": "-7.652527709661931", "hemisphere": "" }, { "year": "", "source": "TROPOMI", "mask_mode": "reference_only", "qc": "all", "scope": "all", "baseline": "GFS", "n_events": "42", "model_wins": "36", "ties": "0", "mean_delta_rmse": "-6.707284485323997", "hemisphere": "" } ], "intervals": [ { "year": "", "source": "OMPS", "mask_mode": "reference_only", "qc": "all", "scope": "all", "baseline": "CAMS", "n_events": "42", "n_clusters": "37", "delta_rmse": "-4.674920069099828", "ci_low": "-7.51066605294371", "ci_high": "-1.8508065467733483", "replicates": "2000", "status": "exploratory_conditional_on_catalog", "hemisphere": "" }, { "year": "", "source": "OMPS", "mask_mode": "reference_only", "qc": "all", "scope": "all", "baseline": "GFS", "n_events": "42", "n_clusters": "37", "delta_rmse": "-5.398602758130958", "ci_low": "-7.6991234462454265", "ci_high": "-2.976004325035646", "replicates": "2000", "status": "exploratory_conditional_on_catalog", "hemisphere": "" }, { "year": "", "source": "TROPOMI", "mask_mode": "reference_only", "qc": "all", "scope": "all", "baseline": "CAMS", "n_events": "42", "n_clusters": "37", "delta_rmse": "-7.652527709661931", "ci_low": "-10.033827785895651", "ci_high": "-5.1199210087319695", "replicates": "2000", "status": "exploratory_conditional_on_catalog", "hemisphere": "" }, { "year": "", "source": "TROPOMI", "mask_mode": "reference_only", "qc": "all", "scope": "all", "baseline": "GFS", "n_events": "42", "n_clusters": "37", "delta_rmse": "-6.707284485323997", "ci_low": "-8.688097630125533", "ci_high": "-4.5278632128054", "replicates": "2000", "status": "exploratory_conditional_on_catalog", "hemisphere": "" } ] }, "supplement": { "rows": [ { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 52.75711185614282, "mae": 35.049494142460645, "bias": 13.600907282243698, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 58.804263372267634, "mae": 47.28232652860177, "bias": 36.880442240244165, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 49.97916934130512, "mae": 32.94095561933398, "bias": 14.74212430796229, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 66.45429134803521, "mae": 47.0020070569796, "bias": 18.38175972386411, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 45.056656268607384, "mae": 28.793050219695967, "bias": 15.05605597627492, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 34.935284977045654, "mae": 27.914465244838166, "bias": 4.915603405180431, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 58.44751292500464, "mae": 50.428618512834824, "bias": 46.17569231305804, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 35.08613234648928, "mae": 28.000632389613557, "bias": 8.617574978783017, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 61.38480135722023, "mae": 51.54879071916853, "bias": 34.94784900483631, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 24.69679229738708, "mae": 20.022379717145647, "bias": 13.906201535179502, "n": 4 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 35.706218025259986, "mae": 28.5568133697946, "bias": 3.0194949232655275, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 56.889183744529625, "mae": 52.494834636944894, "bias": 47.94543434355135, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 35.50086805180336, "mae": 28.517505940814033, "bias": 6.053918165722327, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 52.517790635788764, "mae": 42.6075100516355, "bias": 26.950438028773622, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 29.552401711866963, "mae": 23.947273093115303, "bias": 13.75429534844769, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 28.775878438954944, "mae": 22.950278771859562, "bias": -7.1630108720823324, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 48.23929499232506, "mae": 43.802771868089934, "bias": 37.02070869857577, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 27.581354131840268, "mae": 22.050696853253978, "bias": -4.263448192688071, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 45.63725995402526, "mae": 36.73213162248691, "bias": 15.002632112063637, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 16.110725893123, "mae": 12.84158601482847, "bias": 3.582427861082899, "n": 6 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 35.19554817956676, "mae": 27.56074032738096, "bias": -3.409667387462801, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 30.441310100578157, "mae": 27.135826038178948, "bias": 1.6097006661551312, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 33.385141256522815, "mae": 27.50912019275484, "bias": 5.4054694766089995, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 41.798872527639546, "mae": 34.6457071358817, "bias": 7.536688232421872, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 14.856672113538501, "mae": 11.619603969029015, "bias": 1.6694147019159193, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 19.679339698617728, "mae": 16.692987093244277, "bias": 6.538410967872251, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 42.78097549950705, "mae": 35.2328240167527, "bias": 26.59104505266461, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 21.967188001828184, "mae": 19.09391948881603, "bias": 10.987589881533662, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 45.63309617929258, "mae": 36.92085514976865, "bias": 21.45178471519833, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 16.786803732345234, "mae": 13.136318141392298, "bias": 8.067955889020642, "n": 4 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 24.058351678397276, "mae": 18.629108823994848, "bias": -1.08543342755864, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 46.706225170622105, "mae": 40.00685576529936, "bias": 30.672722976759797, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 24.829019182747505, "mae": 19.65517116135358, "bias": 5.702642312326058, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 46.60187359047473, "mae": 37.80148842087434, "bias": 18.14164838579483, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 16.123092664638957, "mae": 12.808680747770259, "bias": 7.164089130593213, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 27.19706330505763, "mae": 21.269590858912416, "bias": -10.540057791571195, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 41.961585168325506, "mae": 35.16106703953529, "bias": 21.218098612747248, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 24.79864609807826, "mae": 19.134839441642995, "bias": -3.751982051686497, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 43.981415344460224, "mae": 35.57522684863777, "bias": 8.687024021782277, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 15.259457396202313, "mae": 12.371867821561944, "bias": -2.2905352334193436, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 52.54946144513226, "mae": 35.38650567764626, "bias": 13.967206468319242, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 58.80426337226765, "mae": 47.28232652860177, "bias": 36.88044224024417, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "GFS", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 49.28327715228475, "mae": 32.098961113568826, "bias": 14.109228335884884, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 54.754977923348804, "mae": 35.31305984076401, "bias": 12.478950917332398, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 43.14917807304939, "mae": 26.574660910699595, "bias": 14.898167752144035, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 53.741877968419516, "mae": 37.08265790819823, "bias": 14.477357119605662, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 58.80426337226765, "mae": 47.28232652860177, "bias": 36.88044224024417, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "GFS", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 50.54215136247308, "mae": 32.63084558472597, "bias": 14.539358206918669, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 71.29268476067988, "mae": 48.721695061016796, "bias": 14.00495059364721, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 42.656428236132705, "mae": 26.482028905729894, "bias": 14.543658604060203, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 51.70568403736988, "mae": 34.07871746933251, "bias": 12.570475849352391, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 58.80426337226765, "mae": 47.28232652860177, "bias": 36.88044224024417, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "GFS", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 50.82572549806387, "mae": 33.423609518945064, "bias": 13.807118462201652, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 67.6758899004755, "mae": 50.39483735125166, "bias": 16.137133276611944, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 45.133805168263315, "mae": 28.946351722965858, "bias": 14.713288611696482, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 50.99266705194475, "mae": 32.83029414203232, "bias": 13.08326080245781, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 58.80426337226765, "mae": 47.28232652860177, "bias": 36.88044224024417, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "GFS", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 49.08916111293363, "mae": 33.824406348971785, "bias": 16.553886849539627, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 68.01798457490005, "mae": 47.74070650258458, "bias": 21.719606802039284, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 45.79288527775778, "mae": 30.33735244100852, "bias": 15.193249194305347, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 54.381306109360175, "mae": 35.86929551509389, "bias": 13.9062361714834, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 58.80426337226765, "mae": 47.28232652860177, "bias": 36.88044224024417, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "GFS", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 49.548817765905994, "mae": 32.72695553045822, "bias": 14.701029685266638, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 67.83193739830777, "mae": 52.83973652928097, "bias": 27.568157029689704, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 47.63067219192894, "mae": 31.624857118075948, "bias": 15.931915719168531, "n": 3 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 31.971150878696584, "mae": 25.862133098783946, "bias": 3.9249488830566412, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 58.44751292500464, "mae": 50.42861851283483, "bias": 46.175692313058036, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "GFS", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 32.90016708288125, "mae": 26.573868669782367, "bias": 6.974495733351935, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 46.672430133817485, "mae": 38.896434166317896, "bias": 17.613640412830172, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 22.254683041895095, "mae": 18.68122783842541, "bias": 12.374011957077755, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 31.348399322752407, "mae": 25.49571060907273, "bias": 3.48665524437314, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 58.44751292500464, "mae": 50.42861851283483, "bias": 46.175692313058036, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "GFS", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 33.3690175946207, "mae": 26.288095092773435, "bias": 6.866387358165923, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 60.07587213911308, "mae": 47.41609762282599, "bias": 26.193331218901132, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 22.434642876092987, "mae": 18.539859735398064, "bias": 12.29541291736421, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 33.76266475656663, "mae": 27.814246404738654, "bias": 4.223979913620722, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 58.44751292500464, "mae": 50.42861851283483, "bias": 46.175692313058036, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "GFS", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 34.90276516953053, "mae": 27.97332999819801, "bias": 8.847574397495816, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 64.82492797144403, "mae": 57.177908252534415, "bias": 37.35482882545108, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 24.59503745882037, "mae": 20.774576532273066, "bias": 15.02083732968285, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 37.19164811316944, "mae": 31.06728174118769, "bias": 6.249016752697173, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 58.44751292500464, "mae": 50.42861851283483, "bias": 46.175692313058036, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "GFS", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 35.96496477236533, "mae": 29.311004856654577, "bias": 10.330989002046131, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 65.76167492953967, "mae": 57.206605311802456, "bias": 42.512129865373886, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 23.725337165669266, "mae": 19.412546357654392, "bias": 12.9380369640532, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 39.04845430599633, "mae": 29.332954370407833, "bias": 6.693416232154483, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 58.44751292500464, "mae": 50.42861851283483, "bias": 46.175692313058036, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "GFS", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 37.3820168886609, "mae": 29.85686333065941, "bias": 10.068428402855282, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 66.12147108927789, "mae": 57.04690824236189, "bias": 51.065314701625276, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 29.251023438043287, "mae": 22.703688121977304, "bias": 16.902708507719495, "n": 4 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 34.89575366365262, "mae": 28.163984874487017, "bias": 3.016852302825567, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 56.88918374452964, "mae": 52.494834636944894, "bias": 47.94543434355135, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 34.99008705691187, "mae": 28.268329075933224, "bias": 5.748032762744196, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 41.36305042787463, "mae": 32.22575516092913, "bias": 13.029003104703248, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 28.0528733983663, "mae": 22.591545077916134, "bias": 12.937979378600959, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 35.29224634836228, "mae": 28.436589651857165, "bias": 2.6541257281859543, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 56.88918374452964, "mae": 52.494834636944894, "bias": 47.94543434355135, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 35.605331703044364, "mae": 28.7723560049604, "bias": 6.90091333353089, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 50.566845637625256, "mae": 40.7085416419364, "bias": 18.402987905869526, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 29.022974004923466, "mae": 23.34814061609357, "bias": 13.05574986524767, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 35.584434840112344, "mae": 28.47525963513264, "bias": 2.4224683798232642, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 56.88918374452964, "mae": 52.494834636944894, "bias": 47.94543434355135, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 36.08235544427652, "mae": 28.708561304341668, "bias": 6.348102142939038, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 52.10494957459531, "mae": 42.62929905859194, "bias": 26.413908136641012, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 29.731600302185253, "mae": 24.118990441524392, "bias": 13.150170808697439, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 35.80039628104277, "mae": 28.663801041793803, "bias": 2.6839825098855794, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 56.88918374452964, "mae": 52.494834636944894, "bias": 47.94543434355135, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 35.90591499935613, "mae": 29.069691697510724, "bias": 6.371747834243028, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 54.77279752042949, "mae": 46.04593741203863, "bias": 35.43359059312762, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 28.617616052452004, "mae": 23.277147094347928, "bias": 12.557977579191581, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 36.512620197613636, "mae": 29.044431645702378, "bias": 4.320045695607274, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 56.88918374452964, "mae": 52.494834636944894, "bias": 47.94543434355135, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 34.65470219760413, "mae": 27.768591621324173, "bias": 4.900794755154485, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 59.721976836112674, "mae": 51.42801698468137, "bias": 41.47270040352671, "n": 6 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 31.846693646788225, "mae": 26.400542235694513, "bias": 17.069599110500796, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 27.486215962360077, "mae": 22.053118920562437, "bias": -7.354118317712646, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 48.23929499232506, "mae": 43.80277186808994, "bias": 37.02070869857576, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 26.676303616526642, "mae": 21.583975810737964, "bias": -4.498082479200799, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 32.807042203914385, "mae": 26.775828646096937, "bias": 2.2798359564267234, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "2025", "rmse": 12.481558582846988, "mae": 10.09460821889184, "bias": 2.831017396469153, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 28.163515128015018, "mae": 22.475481218537812, "bias": -7.694551257246393, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 48.23929499232506, "mae": 43.80277186808994, "bias": 37.02070869857576, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 27.160389362892005, "mae": 21.73914506180755, "bias": -3.5236711828489464, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 44.432425045592, "mae": 35.88007510222318, "bias": 6.274988250319514, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "2025", "rmse": 14.588980402231558, "mae": 11.79760643871654, "bias": 2.9366598272495117, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 28.78087428701707, "mae": 22.964050482331526, "bias": -7.803579524318649, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 48.23929499232506, "mae": 43.80277186808994, "bias": 37.02070869857576, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 27.709416461701114, "mae": 22.081542414085664, "bias": -4.031327180047622, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 47.79109526164776, "mae": 38.55635154191614, "bias": 13.292132118711471, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "2025", "rmse": 15.8852929407023, "mae": 12.802153032338778, "bias": 2.8828178450144755, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 29.230789449916816, "mae": 23.43729100875343, "bias": -7.435553539800896, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 48.23929499232506, "mae": 43.80277186808994, "bias": 37.02070869857576, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 28.08481297990956, "mae": 22.634081773610713, "bias": -3.9018240775854185, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 48.30277154309371, "mae": 40.19752245575249, "bias": 23.12426827243795, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "2025", "rmse": 16.55186151721694, "mae": 13.344409538536725, "bias": 2.3790229831665655, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 29.855803419388675, "mae": 23.821452229112595, "bias": -5.527251721333076, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 48.23929499232506, "mae": 43.80277186808994, "bias": 37.02070869857576, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 28.012876387114435, "mae": 22.214739206027986, "bias": -5.362336043757573, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 50.00488051151344, "mae": 42.250880366445784, "bias": 30.041935962422528, "n": 6 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "2025", "rmse": 19.740226481045607, "mae": 16.16915284565846, "bias": 6.882621253514787, "n": 6 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 31.515427437014452, "mae": 24.32667904808408, "bias": -4.84599289667039, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 30.441310100578157, "mae": 27.135826038178948, "bias": 1.6097006661551312, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "GFS", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 31.203974327139925, "mae": 24.926575142996658, "bias": 2.6651016961960536, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 43.55778961194475, "mae": 36.83984607514881, "bias": 6.203986176990324, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 9.90714497029663, "mae": 7.502472941080725, "bias": 2.0577103387741786, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 32.08427061963555, "mae": 25.005929129464292, "bias": -6.2719514392671165, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 30.441310100578157, "mae": 27.135826038178948, "bias": 1.6097006661551312, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "GFS", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 31.91832145019262, "mae": 25.954759434291297, "bias": 3.819291033063613, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 49.72615418689972, "mae": 43.641372099376866, "bias": 2.326317342122393, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 9.142220476659112, "mae": 7.668434215727305, "bias": 0.48789774576822587, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 35.01500234909766, "mae": 27.747149658203124, "bias": -3.590443057105658, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 30.441310100578157, "mae": 27.135826038178948, "bias": 1.6097006661551312, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "GFS", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 32.4347087164726, "mae": 26.27005775088356, "bias": 5.359008934384297, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 40.0283465521709, "mae": 34.72147347586497, "bias": 5.130193946475071, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 12.158654066796181, "mae": 10.424817330496648, "bias": 1.50442955380394, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 37.81280190667381, "mae": 29.02575828915551, "bias": -2.01578543526786, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 30.441310100578157, "mae": 27.135826038178948, "bias": 1.6097006661551312, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "GFS", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 34.94601165530024, "mae": 29.96956946963356, "bias": 7.013363938104535, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 38.60790199895058, "mae": 30.36238752092634, "bias": 11.572407459077377, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 14.99069964293993, "mae": 12.784438069661459, "bias": 0.658671933128717, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 38.25233080987914, "mae": 31.69818551199777, "bias": -0.3241641090029795, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 30.441310100578157, "mae": 27.135826038178948, "bias": 1.6097006661551312, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "GFS", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 35.872224398410644, "mae": 30.424639165969122, "bias": 8.1705817812965, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 32.24577658443532, "mae": 27.663456508091514, "bias": 12.450536237444192, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 23.24189569964446, "mae": 19.71785728817894, "bias": 3.6383639381045354, "n": 2 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 19.42663792120308, "mae": 16.786134011404847, "bias": 7.995827484130855, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 42.78097549950706, "mae": 35.2328240167527, "bias": 26.591045052664615, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "GFS", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 20.2785897667175, "mae": 17.545041057041708, "bias": 11.00487294878278, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 34.407703320869814, "mae": 29.098177137829, "bias": 19.834427370343885, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 12.115364235170038, "mae": 10.112168593633736, "bias": 8.092698088146387, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 18.084348979299918, "mae": 15.45561819530668, "bias": 5.222387168520968, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 42.78097549950706, "mae": 35.2328240167527, "bias": 26.591045052664615, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "GFS", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 20.60816954277177, "mae": 17.996343322027293, "bias": 10.85248796372186, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 44.15133578424346, "mae": 37.75886437552316, "bias": 10.5400643484933, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 13.96128330648127, "mae": 11.279758126395087, "bias": 7.238640776134668, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 19.82458793162769, "mae": 16.62442590622674, "bias": 6.927118428548172, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 42.78097549950706, "mae": 35.2328240167527, "bias": 26.591045052664615, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "GFS", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 21.32600101786409, "mae": 18.574181311471115, "bias": 11.988730784824911, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 50.90175327111899, "mae": 43.222280411493216, "bias": 14.80507445562453, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 14.867867399826071, "mae": 12.902935155232745, "bias": 8.85328596205938, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 19.663260030190465, "mae": 16.464994248889738, "bias": 6.729828552972698, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 42.78097549950706, "mae": 35.2328240167527, "bias": 26.591045052664615, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "GFS", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 22.350138946810347, "mae": 19.73652941385905, "bias": 10.09764420645577, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 45.86292618995333, "mae": 36.507611211140954, "bias": 27.79736141023181, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 15.786653284115012, "mae": 13.039320119222003, "bias": 8.722164553687682, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 20.57202638938324, "mae": 18.133763104393367, "bias": 5.816893205188565, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 42.78097549950706, "mae": 35.2328240167527, "bias": 26.591045052664615, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "GFS", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 24.23212304030153, "mae": 21.61750233968099, "bias": 10.994213503882994, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 45.51285895347446, "mae": 38.01734261285691, "bias": 34.281995991298125, "n": 4 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 23.458985454917425, "mae": 18.347408712477915, "bias": 7.4329900650750975, "n": 4 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 22.44516801195603, "mae": 17.44450727542149, "bias": -1.2247606412826961, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 46.7062251706221, "mae": 40.00685576529936, "bias": 30.672722976759797, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 22.622372861978043, "mae": 17.949419289412127, "bias": 4.416969664695621, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 37.177636802329445, "mae": 30.384784806865383, "bias": 10.53329279177299, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 12.998309003908167, "mae": 10.261528063200114, "bias": 6.411398106348874, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 22.71899716522692, "mae": 17.624214937477998, "bias": -1.7564405739812927, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 46.7062251706221, "mae": 40.00685576529936, "bias": 30.672722976759797, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 23.001026675214796, "mae": 18.158568456079067, "bias": 4.177302222327059, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 47.464052898167154, "mae": 39.91046665371324, "bias": 11.268187643412698, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 13.921607238937568, "mae": 11.073454571287538, "bias": 6.149938346174567, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 23.685769278766593, "mae": 18.37370630312984, "bias": -0.8217058742411532, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 46.7062251706221, "mae": 40.00685576529936, "bias": 30.672722976759797, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 23.944465706448135, "mae": 19.09036929818992, "bias": 5.619690903013819, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 49.753095325729575, "mae": 40.92544481364804, "bias": 15.059234136162337, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 15.353017494340182, "mae": 12.356532110324983, "bias": 6.902963209176273, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 24.453140935208005, "mae": 18.807856307922613, "bias": -0.683755107247341, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 46.7062251706221, "mae": 40.00685576529936, "bias": 30.672722976759797, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 26.303702734547166, "mae": 20.92706326464988, "bias": 6.585426144960392, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 47.79708311668439, "mae": 38.14761466256762, "bias": 23.8887113718416, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 16.451499703013873, "mae": 13.465545686712318, "bias": 7.6762006827319755, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 26.655504881511582, "mae": 20.89525929602228, "bias": -0.9405049410407156, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 46.7062251706221, "mae": 40.00685576529936, "bias": 30.672722976759797, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 27.676816799279635, "mae": 22.150435498436902, "bias": 7.713822626633403, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 47.42701017124013, "mae": 39.63913116757742, "bias": 29.958815985784526, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 20.545169288077847, "mae": 16.886343307326353, "bias": 8.679945308534375, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 25.56751546248273, "mae": 19.870640840145562, "bias": -10.67938500529525, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 41.96158516832551, "mae": 35.16106703953529, "bias": 21.218098612747244, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 22.715299248763216, "mae": 17.445441160445494, "bias": -5.037654699316934, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 36.06446568292485, "mae": 29.154923676031324, "bias": 1.0786684277604333, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "2026", "rmse": 12.609199063517577, "mae": 10.325151168254706, "bias": -3.043226257663682, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 26.114681944146476, "mae": 20.355035260779008, "bias": -11.211064937993848, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 41.96158516832551, "mae": 35.16106703953529, "bias": 21.218098612747244, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 23.788870366942508, "mae": 18.252693037522246, "bias": -5.277322141685497, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 46.5870771751278, "mae": 39.44581810606212, "bias": 1.8135632794001437, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "2026", "rmse": 13.466092209283625, "mae": 11.190469131929587, "bias": -3.3046860178379895, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 26.63056359870733, "mae": 20.992134814532267, "bias": -10.27633023825371, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 41.96158516832551, "mae": 35.16106703953529, "bias": 21.218098612747244, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 23.780193929607954, "mae": 18.446278456169303, "bias": -3.8349334609987373, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 47.88357167135059, "mae": 39.79006776799551, "bias": 5.60460977214978, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "2026", "rmse": 14.36428487015716, "mae": 11.84693937080023, "bias": -2.5516611548362818, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 27.462470779887827, "mae": 21.302121622987805, "bias": -10.138379471259897, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 41.96158516832551, "mae": 35.16106703953529, "bias": 21.218098612747244, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 25.850152477826914, "mae": 20.19645499915327, "bias": -2.8691982190521625, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 43.761215341470816, "mae": 34.59523966739575, "bias": 14.434087007829046, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "2026", "rmse": 15.26896856884412, "mae": 12.76754697624412, "bias": -1.77842368128058, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 29.7976211967622, "mae": 23.82802175611743, "bias": -10.39512930505327, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 41.96158516832551, "mae": 35.16106703953529, "bias": 21.218098612747244, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 27.211946438111674, "mae": 21.333329554924642, "bias": -1.7408017373791531, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 42.263699222537284, "mae": 34.89008502570416, "bias": 20.504191621771973, "n": 5 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "2026", "rmse": 19.413526759352372, "mae": 15.729232460581082, "bias": -0.7746790554781834, "n": 5 } ], "events": [ { "region_id": "+60_+010", "center_lat": "60", "center_lon": "10", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2025-01-15", "year": "2025", "quarter": "1", "run_start": "2025-01-13", "run_end": "2025-01-19", "run_days": "7", "start": "2025-01-12", "end": "2025-01-18", "strength": "0.1990850694456832", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "263.08387935744105", "TROPOMI_normal": "338.38291303376883", "TROPOMI_deficit": "75.29903367632778", "OMPS_mean": "265.51089822470317", "OMPS_normal": "331.5094875818358", "OMPS_deficit": "65.99858935713263", "event_id": "station_2025_05", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS_with_ground_coverage", "ground_support": "Brewer" }, { "region_id": "+60_-010", "center_lat": "60", "center_lon": "-10", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2025-03-02", "year": "2025", "quarter": "1", "run_start": "2025-02-28", "run_end": "2025-03-05", "run_days": "6", "start": "2025-02-27", "end": "2025-03-05", "strength": "0.2254147627238599", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "301.43374656877484", "TROPOMI_normal": "389.15503686692847", "TROPOMI_deficit": "87.72129029815363", "OMPS_mean": "294.97459919839633", "OMPS_normal": "387.5184642711583", "OMPS_deficit": "92.54386507276196", "event_id": "station_2025_02", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS_with_ground_coverage", "ground_support": "Dobson" }, { "region_id": "-45_-070", "center_lat": "-45", "center_lon": "-70", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "SH", "peak_date": "2025-08-07", "year": "2025", "quarter": "3", "run_start": "2025-08-06", "run_end": "2025-08-07", "run_days": "2", "start": "2025-08-04", "end": "2025-08-10", "strength": "0.1971778301023801", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "240.09683238064648", "TROPOMI_normal": "322.62413698027495", "TROPOMI_deficit": "82.52730459962848", "OMPS_mean": "255.84061036791195", "OMPS_normal": "318.67656370343894", "OMPS_deficit": "62.835953335526995", "event_id": "station_2025_06", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS_with_ground_coverage", "ground_support": "Dobson" }, { "region_id": "+60_-150", "center_lat": "60", "center_lon": "-150", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2025-10-04", "year": "2025", "quarter": "4", "run_start": "2025-10-03", "run_end": "2025-10-05", "run_days": "3", "start": "2025-10-01", "end": "2025-10-07", "strength": "0.1728903946333007", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "280.5864097910402", "TROPOMI_normal": "339.2372763784337", "TROPOMI_deficit": "58.65086658739352", "OMPS_mean": "271.1442597106689", "OMPS_normal": "333.57652858078126", "OMPS_deficit": "62.43226887011235", "event_id": "station_2025_07", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS_with_ground_coverage", "ground_support": "Dobson" }, { "region_id": "+60_+010", "center_lat": "60", "center_lon": "10", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2025-10-07", "year": "2025", "quarter": "4", "run_start": "2025-10-06", "run_end": "2025-10-07", "run_days": "2", "start": "2025-10-04", "end": "2025-10-10", "strength": "0.1503561926941904", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "251.56961676944184", "TROPOMI_normal": "296.0883309055829", "TROPOMI_deficit": "44.51871413614106", "OMPS_mean": "243.201010271372", "OMPS_normal": "288.595098203405", "OMPS_deficit": "45.39408793203296", "event_id": "station_2025_09", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS_with_ground_coverage", "ground_support": "Brewer" }, { "region_id": "+60_-030", "center_lat": "60", "center_lon": "-30", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2025-10-24", "year": "2025", "quarter": "4", "run_start": "2025-10-23", "run_end": "2025-10-25", "run_days": "3", "start": "2025-10-21", "end": "2025-10-27", "strength": "0.1440747512249563", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "263.8962532631553", "TROPOMI_normal": "310.57861300400515", "TROPOMI_deficit": "46.68235974084985", "OMPS_mean": "258.04618863028065", "OMPS_normal": "301.48215512929795", "OMPS_deficit": "43.4359664990173", "event_id": "station_2025_10", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS_with_ground_coverage", "ground_support": "Brewer+Dobson" }, { "region_id": "+40_-010", "center_lat": "40", "center_lon": "-10", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2026-02-17", "year": "2026", "quarter": "1", "run_start": "2026-02-16", "run_end": "2026-02-17", "run_days": "2", "start": "2026-02-14", "end": "2026-02-20", "strength": "0.1026548942583159", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "293.9410035061173", "TROPOMI_normal": "327.5674003516916", "TROPOMI_deficit": "33.626396845574334", "OMPS_mean": "288.6548030331415", "OMPS_normal": "325.3225672712653", "OMPS_deficit": "36.66776423812382", "event_id": "station_2026_11", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS_with_ground_coverage", "ground_support": "Brewer+Dobson" }, { "region_id": "+50_-010", "center_lat": "50", "center_lon": "-10", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "NH", "peak_date": "2026-03-26", "year": "2026", "quarter": "1", "run_start": "2026-03-26", "run_end": "2026-03-27", "run_days": "2", "start": "2026-03-23", "end": "2026-03-29", "strength": "0.1652233334398067", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "307.6777362082881", "TROPOMI_normal": "368.574911749887", "TROPOMI_deficit": "60.897175541598926", "OMPS_mean": "301.44287533525727", "OMPS_normal": "363.27804382077994", "OMPS_deficit": "61.83516848552267", "event_id": "station_2026_08", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS_with_ground_coverage", "ground_support": "Brewer" }, { "region_id": "-55_+150", "center_lat": "-55", "center_lon": "150", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "SH", "peak_date": "2026-08-18", "year": "2026", "quarter": "3", "run_start": "2026-08-17", "run_end": "2026-08-19", "run_days": "3", "start": "2026-08-15", "end": "2026-08-21", "strength": "0.2031482003914804", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "270.14218699210073", "TROPOMI_normal": "339.0118302108588", "TROPOMI_deficit": "68.86964321875809", "OMPS_mean": "261.44475817791084", "OMPS_normal": "339.8786475191343", "OMPS_deficit": "78.43388934122345", "event_id": "station_2026_03", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS_with_ground_coverage", "ground_support": "Dobson" }, { "region_id": "-45_-070", "center_lat": "-45", "center_lon": "-70", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "SH", "peak_date": "2026-08-23", "year": "2026", "quarter": "3", "run_start": "2026-08-22", "run_end": "2026-08-24", "run_days": "3", "start": "2026-08-20", "end": "2026-08-26", "strength": "0.2019354990743478", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "265.8464902013718", "TROPOMI_normal": "333.1140401471611", "TROPOMI_deficit": "67.26754994578931", "OMPS_mean": "257.5029071176861", "OMPS_normal": "327.3369909424338", "OMPS_deficit": "69.83408382474767", "event_id": "station_2026_04", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS_with_ground_coverage", "ground_support": "Dobson" }, { "region_id": "-55_+150", "center_lat": "-55", "center_lon": "150", "half_lat": "5", "half_lon": "10", "hemisphere": "SH", "peak_date": "2026-08-31", "year": "2026", "quarter": "3", "run_start": "2026-08-31", "run_end": "2026-09-04", "run_days": "5", "start": "2026-08-28", "end": "2026-09-03", "strength": "0.2493529590911787", "complete_inputs": "True", "bounded_run": "True", "similar_to_vargin": "True", "TROPOMI_mean": "269.79156815057416", "TROPOMI_normal": "359.4120184953142", "TROPOMI_deficit": "89.62045034474005", "OMPS_mean": "256.95111316354877", "OMPS_normal": "353.90410510695995", "OMPS_deficit": "96.95299194341118", "event_id": "station_2026_01", "kind": "regional_deficit", "selection_source": "joint_TROPOMI_OMPS_with_ground_coverage", "ground_support": "Dobson" } ] }, "groundChecks": [ { "id": "all", "n": 22217, "stations": 45, "tcoscope": 19.763022727813315, "cams": 24.098806162643324 }, { "id": "Brewer", "n": 9250, "stations": 21, "tcoscope": 19.280784863690783, "cams": 25.387985771779444 }, { "id": "Dobson", "n": 10310, "stations": 25, "tcoscope": 20.96038216220859, "cams": 23.544251719480663 }, { "id": "direct_sun", "n": 16195, "stations": 41, "tcoscope": 17.187110142148143, "cams": 21.353997411548526 }, { "id": "station_balanced", "n": 22217, "stations": 45, "tcoscope": 18.912354467793545, "cams": 22.79675396679065 } ], "anomalies": { "events": [ { "year": "2025", "kind": "antarctic_hole", "area_km2": "20207140.66979026", "coverage": "0.9975202556230534", "eligible": "True", "center_lat": "-77.4000015258789", "center_lon": "34.19999957084656", "event_id": "2025_antarctic_hole_1", "peak_date": "2025-09-27", "start": "2025-09-24", "end": "2025-09-30", "selection_source": "OMPS" }, { "year": "2025", "kind": "antarctic_hole", "area_km2": "16524335.751437925", "coverage": "0.9893602445624934", "eligible": "True", "center_lat": "-79.79999542236328", "center_lon": "21.000000089406967", "event_id": "2025_antarctic_hole_2", "peak_date": "2025-10-26", "start": "2025-10-23", "end": "2025-10-29", "selection_source": "OMPS" }, { "year": "2025", "kind": "high_ozone", "area_km2": "9697441.707455166", "coverage": "0.9525356614221347", "eligible": "True", "center_lat": "42.60000228881836", "center_lon": "39.00000035762787", "event_id": "2025_high_ozone_1", "peak_date": "2025-02-20", "start": "2025-02-17", "end": "2025-02-23", "selection_source": "OMPS" }, { "year": "2025", "kind": "high_ozone", "area_km2": "6765076.068051586", "coverage": "0.7919995563517783", "eligible": "True", "center_lat": "58.20000076293945", "center_lon": "-85.79999327659607", "event_id": "2025_high_ozone_2", "peak_date": "2025-11-30", "start": "2025-11-27", "end": "2025-12-03", "selection_source": "OMPS" }, { "year": "2025", "kind": "nh_low_ozone", "area_km2": "318389.78843704256", "coverage": "0.8948555888635031", "eligible": "True", "center_lat": "41.39999771118164", "center_lon": "-56.99999928474426", "event_id": "2025_nh_low_ozone_1", "peak_date": "2025-10-31", "start": "2025-10-28", "end": "2025-11-03", "selection_source": "OMPS" }, { "year": "2025", "kind": "nh_low_ozone", "area_km2": "230000.5696893775", "coverage": "0.9397915149376556", "eligible": "True", "center_lat": "72.5999984741211", "center_lon": "-40.200001895427704", "event_id": "2025_nh_low_ozone_2", "peak_date": "2025-02-16", "start": "2025-02-13", "end": "2025-02-19", "selection_source": "OMPS" }, { "year": "2025", "kind": "rapid_rise", "area_km2": "7899876.372449189", "coverage": "0.9336058002726996", "eligible": "True", "center_lat": "43.79999923706055", "center_lon": "-27.000001072883606", "event_id": "2025_rapid_rise_1", "peak_date": "2025-02-16", "start": "2025-02-13", "end": "2025-02-19", "selection_source": "OMPS" }, { "year": "2025", "kind": "rapid_rise", "area_km2": "6818711.684023139", "coverage": "0.7742293833218363", "eligible": "True", "center_lat": "37.79999923706055", "center_lon": "-56.99999928474426", "event_id": "2025_rapid_rise_2", "peak_date": "2025-12-26", "start": "2025-12-23", "end": "2025-12-29", "selection_source": "OMPS" }, { "year": "2026", "kind": "antarctic_hole", "area_km2": "23471177.64628592", "coverage": "0.9658349817062752", "eligible": "True", "center_lat": "-77.4000015258789", "center_lon": "-156.59999012947083", "event_id": "2026_antarctic_hole_1", "peak_date": "2026-09-17", "start": "2026-09-14", "end": "2026-09-20", "selection_source": "OMPS" }, { "year": "2026", "kind": "antarctic_hole", "area_km2": "1736759.0414451803", "coverage": "0.7710125738375052", "eligible": "True", "center_lat": "-70.19999694824219", "center_lon": "-101.39999985694885", "event_id": "2026_antarctic_hole_2", "peak_date": "2026-08-20", "start": "2026-08-17", "end": "2026-08-23", "selection_source": "OMPS" }, { "year": "2026", "kind": "high_ozone", "area_km2": "27942629.254355617", "coverage": "1.0", "eligible": "True", "center_lat": "71.4000015258789", "center_lon": "-137.4000084400177", "event_id": "2026_high_ozone_1", "peak_date": "2026-03-09", "start": "2026-03-06", "end": "2026-03-12", "selection_source": "OMPS" }, { "year": "2026", "kind": "high_ozone", "area_km2": "24389278.073614046", "coverage": "1.0", "eligible": "True", "center_lat": "57.0", "center_lon": "-10.199999660253525", "event_id": "2026_high_ozone_2", "peak_date": "2026-04-12", "start": "2026-04-09", "end": "2026-04-15", "selection_source": "OMPS" }, { "year": "2026", "kind": "rapid_rise", "area_km2": "14214325.95103151", "coverage": "0.8516081001799062", "eligible": "True", "center_lat": "51.0", "center_lon": "-0.6000000145286322", "event_id": "2026_rapid_rise_1", "peak_date": "2026-01-28", "start": "2026-01-25", "end": "2026-01-31", "selection_source": "OMPS" }, { "year": "2026", "kind": "rapid_rise", "area_km2": "10371806.061675463", "coverage": "1.0", "eligible": "True", "center_lat": "66.5999984741211", "center_lon": "-153.00000429153442", "event_id": "2026_rapid_rise_2", "peak_date": "2026-03-18", "start": "2026-03-15", "end": "2026-03-21", "selection_source": "OMPS" } ], "rows": [ { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 15.900387700963439, "mae": 12.156499500274657, "bias": -8.857575702667237, "n": 160 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 53.79558985783426, "mae": 40.12478733062744, "bias": -11.767073059082033, "n": 160 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 16.355718945263426, "mae": 12.890936241149902, "bias": 2.2120035171508787, "n": 160 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 53.23326649778738, "mae": 37.04360092163086, "bias": -0.3807296752929693, "n": 160 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 15.290216820623845, "mae": 12.300475177764891, "bias": -10.295940494537353, "n": 160 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 31.417592952215642, "mae": 21.2589990234375, "bias": -3.6679943847656236, "n": 350 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 49.34514522146184, "mae": 41.293312247140065, "bias": -23.42221936907087, "n": 350 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 31.565228153743423, "mae": 21.59017272949219, "bias": 0.9685863385881711, "n": 350 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 54.90155571602538, "mae": 39.054011605399, "bias": 6.945248543875559, "n": 350 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 22.826039144753814, "mae": 15.274386509486607, "bias": -0.38230904715401637, "n": 350 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 46.578518621922534, "mae": 33.26480772144566, "bias": -5.809257817711331, "n": 761075 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 61.52436433488261, "mae": 47.07083759452637, "bias": -22.338676726800387, "n": 761075 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 46.39285023814536, "mae": 33.66808137825189, "bias": 0.720144359847646, "n": 761075 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 57.65158503206965, "mae": 41.96773385717981, "bias": 3.953836869602836, "n": 761075 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 37.05904116793585, "mae": 26.603914033149472, "bias": -1.7355737671131815, "n": 761075 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 37.50391085783523, "mae": 26.29226694122569, "bias": -5.968623533456455, "n": 856700 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 58.524422265082165, "mae": 44.37057569855652, "bias": -21.262620979223417, "n": 856700 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 37.41375047568809, "mae": 26.653459903704928, "bias": 0.16504760402128954, "n": 856700 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 53.62440038784204, "mae": 38.87528276115188, "bias": 4.527586060295956, "n": 856700 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 28.256290375489883, "mae": 19.375669227713445, "bias": -1.8721877309125374, "n": 856700 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 25.66856735894476, "mae": 19.166939905003844, "bias": -10.317397942941783, "n": 820990 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 58.93896911709835, "mae": 45.92016145251392, "bias": -26.447906282321384, "n": 820990 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 26.170595153860727, "mae": 19.32789201343789, "bias": -4.056109274336306, "n": 820990 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 51.69285250061242, "mae": 36.97874804593136, "bias": -0.22393972495813153, "n": 820990 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 15.860803721059684, "mae": 12.223366278051248, "bias": -5.988460876703473, "n": 820990 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:high_ozone", "rmse": 30.20464538951851, "mae": 22.6323732816256, "bias": -14.238517643855172, "n": 130 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:high_ozone", "rmse": 60.502880360594496, "mae": 51.22533076359676, "bias": -51.22533076359676, "n": 130 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:high_ozone", "rmse": 29.88126272079211, "mae": 22.01709796612079, "bias": -11.768443180964546, "n": 130 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:high_ozone", "rmse": 51.21411564826169, "mae": 40.512424457256614, "bias": -24.53617107684796, "n": 130 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:high_ozone", "rmse": 22.746204624360317, "mae": 16.92951843261719, "bias": -11.743587317833537, "n": 130 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:high_ozone", "rmse": 30.151508438371767, "mae": 22.250604954769738, "bias": -10.172648540296054, "n": 95 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:high_ozone", "rmse": 59.321580307232146, "mae": 47.29265779194079, "bias": -43.4548095703125, "n": 95 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:high_ozone", "rmse": 28.680126269139887, "mae": 20.513932784231088, "bias": -6.971462209601152, "n": 95 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:high_ozone", "rmse": 52.61537283110426, "mae": 41.122344520970394, "bias": -25.412026495682564, "n": 95 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:high_ozone", "rmse": 27.286436018388915, "mae": 21.553601459703952, "bias": -4.033167788856909, "n": 95 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:high_ozone", "rmse": 43.53122939940667, "mae": 33.567944225602524, "bias": -15.709633247494764, "n": 34415 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:high_ozone", "rmse": 74.49899307722775, "mae": 61.23513287019259, "bias": -59.9273315412556, "n": 34415 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:high_ozone", "rmse": 40.89533616450464, "mae": 31.15996107130596, "bias": -10.992061842924192, "n": 34415 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:high_ozone", "rmse": 55.08642399000494, "mae": 44.211349729327644, "bias": -26.676047263889355, "n": 34415 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:high_ozone", "rmse": 33.83581255031562, "mae": 25.627572005360594, "bias": -4.000589632269079, "n": 34415 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:high_ozone", "rmse": 38.33214319646681, "mae": 29.088830347037415, "bias": -17.429751514243023, "n": 49905 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:high_ozone", "rmse": 72.23244022934175, "mae": 61.638490451978114, "bias": -60.987393973595445, "n": 49905 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:high_ozone", "rmse": 36.25185007609924, "mae": 27.00461835228639, "bias": -12.954595761189333, "n": 49905 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:high_ozone", "rmse": 53.532913366349426, "mae": 42.187031956185784, "bias": -28.41304033807993, "n": 49905 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:high_ozone", "rmse": 27.79977586217427, "mae": 19.67320184730358, "bias": -6.476819440582357, "n": 49905 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:high_ozone", "rmse": 29.05379110250696, "mae": 22.583462268948587, "bias": -17.29067432801646, "n": 54460 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:high_ozone", "rmse": 78.11705933580453, "mae": 65.25630154648223, "bias": -64.30890315634178, "n": 54460 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:high_ozone", "rmse": 26.81762124470724, "mae": 20.72875807987565, "bias": -12.74722181308102, "n": 54460 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:high_ozone", "rmse": 49.7211147150895, "mae": 39.09353322863783, "bias": -27.000136276595818, "n": 54460 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:high_ozone", "rmse": 18.987355180616547, "mae": 14.751130854936505, "bias": -6.086960341891183, "n": 54460 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:nh_low_ozone", "rmse": 30.085264198175725, "mae": 26.733633858816958, "bias": -14.312627301897306, "n": 35 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:nh_low_ozone", "rmse": 68.2848403042507, "mae": 63.573327636718766, "bias": 63.573327636718766, "n": 35 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:nh_low_ozone", "rmse": 24.203279459753517, "mae": 20.348726457868295, "bias": -5.042214529854896, "n": 35 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:nh_low_ozone", "rmse": 36.18129908920455, "mae": 30.196426130022317, "bias": -8.974328613281235, "n": 35 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:nh_low_ozone", "rmse": 21.05373994540105, "mae": 17.62803397042411, "bias": 7.418212890625014, "n": 35 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:nh_low_ozone", "rmse": 24.45185288106684, "mae": 20.08163364955357, "bias": -7.598163713727678, "n": 35 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:nh_low_ozone", "rmse": 74.61834852968597, "mae": 70.28092302594867, "bias": 70.28092302594867, "n": 35 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:nh_low_ozone", "rmse": 21.654937116241175, "mae": 17.10921369280134, "bias": 1.6793291364397323, "n": 35 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:nh_low_ozone", "rmse": 35.0566582941924, "mae": 29.73311331612723, "bias": -2.264422607421875, "n": 35 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:nh_low_ozone", "rmse": 24.87815606110332, "mae": 21.23697248186384, "bias": 14.154815673828125, "n": 35 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:nh_low_ozone", "rmse": 28.758712598761903, "mae": 21.499878645807506, "bias": 5.37181324688832, "n": 32445 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:nh_low_ozone", "rmse": 60.04030924571222, "mae": 43.093496938414056, "bias": 41.124736492364896, "n": 32445 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:nh_low_ozone", "rmse": 33.23777223079558, "mae": 23.724849052783533, "bias": 12.638974120022954, "n": 32445 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:nh_low_ozone", "rmse": 46.806295479976356, "mae": 37.69799715413771, "bias": 28.04043311785888, "n": 32445 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:nh_low_ozone", "rmse": 36.21145326941436, "mae": 28.256530619908915, "bias": 24.410262969928258, "n": 32445 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:nh_low_ozone", "rmse": 23.58264369625038, "mae": 16.111879434664043, "bias": 3.1450640080984686, "n": 45630 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:nh_low_ozone", "rmse": 52.61212850020961, "mae": 36.86711491234224, "bias": 33.8667178050686, "n": 45630 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:nh_low_ozone", "rmse": 27.82986967026478, "mae": 18.11309553282125, "bias": 9.333392146828574, "n": 45630 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:nh_low_ozone", "rmse": 46.061075370582074, "mae": 36.445135313956584, "bias": 27.547252018470182, "n": 45630 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:nh_low_ozone", "rmse": 31.42974436705189, "mae": 23.692428496432473, "bias": 21.52552033966139, "n": 45630 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:nh_low_ozone", "rmse": 23.518975547893536, "mae": 17.789874833725353, "bias": -4.6668045943599425, "n": 27605 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:nh_low_ozone", "rmse": 68.11255496272543, "mae": 54.413607152391364, "bias": 51.80243452685165, "n": 27605 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:nh_low_ozone", "rmse": 27.592936768424114, "mae": 20.876873395441024, "bias": 8.13437312577855, "n": 27605 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:nh_low_ozone", "rmse": 42.656909500582366, "mae": 34.08177152098707, "bias": 16.955913146434433, "n": 27605 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:nh_low_ozone", "rmse": 27.775184927195646, "mae": 21.983881401757337, "bias": 17.985546507394467, "n": 27605 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:rapid_rise", "rmse": 35.233210887559466, "mae": 27.84007547433036, "bias": -12.653948800223217, "n": 175 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:rapid_rise", "rmse": 37.70746703381911, "mae": 29.644090227399552, "bias": -25.006742989676344, "n": 175 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:rapid_rise", "rmse": 31.84670217799253, "mae": 25.705092878069202, "bias": -8.468684605189736, "n": 175 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:rapid_rise", "rmse": 34.56640807513429, "mae": 24.66161474609375, "bias": -12.971863141741075, "n": 175 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:rapid_rise", "rmse": 20.441092408052956, "mae": 13.83011600167411, "bias": -5.760907854352682, "n": 175 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:rapid_rise", "rmse": 43.69879769970804, "mae": 37.2752685546875, "bias": 37.2752685546875, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:rapid_rise", "rmse": 32.182464599609375, "mae": 32.182464599609375, "bias": -32.182464599609375, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:rapid_rise", "rmse": 47.13920984457903, "mae": 42.89791259765625, "bias": 42.89791259765625, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:rapid_rise", "rmse": 39.38895553184176, "mae": 29.629150390625, "bias": 6.438525390625, "n": 5 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:rapid_rise", "rmse": 7.729364345418673, "mae": 6.671185302734375, "bias": 5.446221923828125, "n": 5 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:rapid_rise", "rmse": 47.58533936200909, "mae": 35.59737689882268, "bias": -2.9279808576914927, "n": 36285 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:rapid_rise", "rmse": 43.24436354737934, "mae": 33.13947970934014, "bias": -18.431085613137174, "n": 36285 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:rapid_rise", "rmse": 47.03216418368601, "mae": 35.50892851669209, "bias": 0.5845838640869104, "n": 36285 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:rapid_rise", "rmse": 46.52670393319246, "mae": 35.66449371436472, "bias": -4.589214520359288, "n": 36285 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:rapid_rise", "rmse": 42.15156782252296, "mae": 31.66082052278323, "bias": 5.40333140006041, "n": 36285 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:rapid_rise", "rmse": 47.48535556316943, "mae": 33.58168246600186, "bias": -5.0396290959510575, "n": 56390 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:rapid_rise", "rmse": 45.606858374309745, "mae": 33.79270263711178, "bias": -21.896957764479723, "n": 56390 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:rapid_rise", "rmse": 46.68048075247871, "mae": 33.47915299463461, "bias": -1.9800582239344229, "n": 56390 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:rapid_rise", "rmse": 44.99851406328307, "mae": 33.66321328706847, "bias": -7.492946996966974, "n": 56390 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:rapid_rise", "rmse": 38.18907018551107, "mae": 26.374365666171954, "bias": 1.5754280477848335, "n": 56390 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:rapid_rise", "rmse": 36.27514031139334, "mae": 26.335114841569542, "bias": -9.099101346451809, "n": 57400 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:rapid_rise", "rmse": 46.15726143118299, "mae": 34.355501240176, "bias": -26.20715377560754, "n": 57400 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:rapid_rise", "rmse": 34.053377870978935, "mae": 24.853437832452464, "bias": -6.026306119090213, "n": 57400 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:rapid_rise", "rmse": 45.9573697134153, "mae": 34.149718064872864, "bias": -11.770635701840021, "n": 57400 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025:rapid_rise", "rmse": 18.244982410012234, "mae": 12.994907247833426, "bias": -2.6747042481204604, "n": 57400 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 32.04190098038442, "mae": 24.96533534458705, "bias": 5.022117978050597, "n": 105 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 42.772009827583446, "mae": 35.49881504603795, "bias": 16.277017938523066, "n": 105 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 30.054552249772673, "mae": 23.925514410109745, "bias": 7.612321108863468, "n": 105 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 53.00154687600759, "mae": 43.582308727446055, "bias": 16.504932948521205, "n": 105 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 21.63764929960816, "mae": 17.141106102353053, "bias": 7.7461421421595995, "n": 105 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 22.408098757715532, "mae": 16.766142053657003, "bias": -0.9762057034506858, "n": 646925 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 38.93526886241423, "mae": 31.58954759158917, "bias": 19.50855195387203, "n": 646925 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 23.896467418358963, "mae": 18.605924174988058, "bias": 5.16864014351932, "n": 646925 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 40.62381859709289, "mae": 31.553748378532323, "bias": 7.347160488801806, "n": 646925 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 18.941045184658247, "mae": 14.753795097186897, "bias": 5.959684328992906, "n": 646925 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 23.0165541666752, "mae": 17.453201067829223, "bias": -6.863593712962484, "n": 732250 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 35.374721336849376, "mae": 28.259790991064143, "bias": 11.829962668010921, "n": 732250 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 24.07480009242576, "mae": 18.70548152134549, "bias": -0.5272891165794602, "n": 732250 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 38.92953186446954, "mae": 29.870832597700627, "bias": 0.5833500100311321, "n": 732250 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:antarctic_hole", "rmse": 15.25101581132264, "mae": 12.00551261312882, "bias": -1.0951027262467412, "n": 732250 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:high_ozone", "rmse": 42.7093039779655, "mae": 30.001669761256164, "bias": -15.002481079101562, "n": 190 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:high_ozone", "rmse": 68.56099165557826, "mae": 50.91542037160772, "bias": -45.11028603001645, "n": 190 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:high_ozone", "rmse": 38.90133113578361, "mae": 27.50272210372121, "bias": -10.115375719572368, "n": 190 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:high_ozone", "rmse": 59.897705241183544, "mae": 43.84352192125822, "bias": -8.809474904913651, "n": 190 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:high_ozone", "rmse": 24.406257150138156, "mae": 17.673378392269736, "bias": -5.397675203022204, "n": 190 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:high_ozone", "rmse": 36.13505622550028, "mae": 26.1491943359375, "bias": -13.246254882812499, "n": 75 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:high_ozone", "rmse": 83.65323723814012, "mae": 76.0424442545573, "bias": -76.0424442545573, "n": 75 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:high_ozone", "rmse": 35.817770440901484, "mae": 26.009768880208334, "bias": -7.8559497070312485, "n": 75 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:high_ozone", "rmse": 47.43306654276961, "mae": 38.215532470703124, "bias": -1.5117289225260402, "n": 75 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:high_ozone", "rmse": 24.85017472028413, "mae": 18.607449381510413, "bias": -7.475199381510415, "n": 75 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:high_ozone", "rmse": 54.4478545979071, "mae": 41.46925879970324, "bias": -3.203349181916107, "n": 48035 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:high_ozone", "rmse": 81.44582799822551, "mae": 68.26737085507582, "bias": -63.43689462627587, "n": 48035 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:high_ozone", "rmse": 52.9154503432512, "mae": 39.99409292136954, "bias": 5.127203134664375, "n": 48035 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:high_ozone", "rmse": 54.51370439960867, "mae": 42.313422524763276, "bias": 4.208315261592885, "n": 48035 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:high_ozone", "rmse": 44.58305706966567, "mae": 33.199915570797664, "bias": 5.6406447887832485, "n": 48035 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:high_ozone", "rmse": 35.14154430110619, "mae": 25.666596766389418, "bias": -7.218709469558731, "n": 54905 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:high_ozone", "rmse": 84.22980595356034, "mae": 70.75772787223173, "bias": -64.53085249549136, "n": 54905 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:high_ozone", "rmse": 33.908497096969135, "mae": 24.956286920367123, "bias": 0.9365323462659392, "n": 54905 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:high_ozone", "rmse": 53.994974463674836, "mae": 41.590181162738396, "bias": -0.23965068841067733, "n": 54905 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:high_ozone", "rmse": 22.186185618415895, "mae": 17.16705928558216, "bias": 1.9968460355431052, "n": 54905 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:high_ozone", "rmse": 36.98899083179725, "mae": 27.409384285878208, "bias": -12.959849916814353, "n": 58835 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:high_ozone", "rmse": 87.91068800004652, "mae": 74.89311624952184, "bias": -71.56812643238531, "n": 58835 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:high_ozone", "rmse": 35.08579408122405, "mae": 25.693553784257368, "bias": -4.640800804095162, "n": 58835 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:high_ozone", "rmse": 53.222857558113766, "mae": 40.53436043989764, "bias": -6.448962023478545, "n": 58835 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:high_ozone", "rmse": 22.01011557437791, "mae": 16.49191868042934, "bias": -3.83216735375075, "n": 58835 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:rapid_rise", "rmse": 37.12740150842714, "mae": 29.570911244537864, "bias": -6.900622662043169, "n": 295 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:rapid_rise", "rmse": 83.77980297251395, "mae": 73.67702533269333, "bias": -71.92856197033899, "n": 295 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:rapid_rise", "rmse": 35.507235352255634, "mae": 28.02789867336467, "bias": -4.196813654495499, "n": 295 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:rapid_rise", "rmse": 50.263281390535994, "mae": 41.16812706898835, "bias": -7.908476645259536, "n": 295 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:rapid_rise", "rmse": 25.66131191244795, "mae": 20.314307861328125, "bias": 0.760387873245496, "n": 295 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:rapid_rise", "rmse": 30.603415521690575, "mae": 25.593509826660156, "bias": -8.139173126220703, "n": 80 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:rapid_rise", "rmse": 78.90675621393342, "mae": 72.44123344421386, "bias": -72.44123344421386, "n": 80 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:rapid_rise", "rmse": 30.67228429787224, "mae": 24.62874328613281, "bias": -5.507813262939454, "n": 80 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:rapid_rise", "rmse": 46.88926340922165, "mae": 38.71249130249023, "bias": -10.889506530761718, "n": 80 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:rapid_rise", "rmse": 20.531282015828854, "mae": 16.502372894287106, "bias": 1.1970405578613275, "n": 80 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:rapid_rise", "rmse": 50.79800252723912, "mae": 40.76058210959096, "bias": -4.753618112947619, "n": 53280 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:rapid_rise", "rmse": 79.66935950875286, "mae": 68.95609128815777, "bias": -67.10491092963467, "n": 53280 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:rapid_rise", "rmse": 48.90608665594967, "mae": 39.23125419811856, "bias": -0.18765581269967735, "n": 53280 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:rapid_rise", "rmse": 50.56747761839461, "mae": 40.16691206190205, "bias": 0.9263785084880972, "n": 53280 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:rapid_rise", "rmse": 36.97668221028087, "mae": 29.262495239207748, "bias": 6.751550186134432, "n": 53280 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:rapid_rise", "rmse": 37.65357659646158, "mae": 29.387061771178757, "bias": -7.325291197692869, "n": 59770 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:rapid_rise", "rmse": 83.08393696427895, "mae": 71.32619776255986, "bias": -68.92015917487647, "n": 59770 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:rapid_rise", "rmse": 37.18551240559974, "mae": 29.063087855377827, "bias": -2.8443377115481083, "n": 59770 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:rapid_rise", "rmse": 51.35340742203017, "mae": 40.889467529027705, "bias": -1.3749347115089579, "n": 59770 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:rapid_rise", "rmse": 23.424530075962824, "mae": 18.429568484368918, "bias": 2.829536549075246, "n": 59770 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:rapid_rise", "rmse": 38.79847639731472, "mae": 30.45752526052853, "bias": -13.163656571393144, "n": 60270 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:rapid_rise", "rmse": 87.08545323468607, "mae": 75.70908142619663, "bias": -74.44637677498616, "n": 60270 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:rapid_rise", "rmse": 37.22432029832265, "mae": 29.112181505316812, "bias": -8.674418050261789, "n": 60270 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:rapid_rise", "rmse": 51.63987148532486, "mae": 41.105856431963524, "bias": -7.397885059410034, "n": 60270 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2026:rapid_rise", "rmse": 22.94247820503952, "mae": 18.29557071469475, "bias": -2.747599738250177, "n": 60270 } ] }, "vargin": [ { "source": "OMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "may_peak", "rmse": 10.493913143082963, "mae": 8.946427703894818, "bias": 8.502197347095194, "n": 80 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "may_peak", "rmse": 42.12650875398825, "mae": 41.54778519382479, "bias": 41.54778519382479, "n": 80 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "may_peak", "rmse": 24.58490364749261, "mae": 23.28529100074544, "bias": 23.28529100074544, "n": 80 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "may_peak", "rmse": 33.07033542981494, "mae": 32.48300089207319, "bias": 32.48300089207319, "n": 80 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "may_peak", "rmse": 20.308258831996174, "mae": 19.962927746996808, "bias": 19.962927746996808, "n": 80 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "may_peak", "rmse": 12.64639287054743, "mae": 11.544625770317307, "bias": 1.4430329862835731, "n": 240 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "may_peak", "rmse": 38.7804221429559, "mae": 37.4086052477281, "bias": 37.4086052477281, "n": 240 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "may_peak", "rmse": 19.89234941598592, "mae": 16.697225607366125, "bias": 15.732714709021126, "n": 240 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "may_peak", "rmse": 32.592741709972834, "mae": 30.95720341515158, "bias": 30.929952945891614, "n": 240 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "may_peak", "rmse": 18.993421210374624, "mae": 16.400935376384833, "bias": 15.886252731776445, "n": 240 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "may_peak", "rmse": 10.160250693339874, "mae": 9.019787336884736, "bias": -8.686751959922356, "n": 240 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "may_peak", "rmse": 28.151736817939888, "mae": 27.27882030152216, "bias": 27.27882030152216, "n": 240 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "may_peak", "rmse": 8.187922740630878, "mae": 6.260550182713674, "bias": 5.602929762815196, "n": 240 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "may_peak", "rmse": 22.58375904182941, "mae": 20.837272018331262, "bias": 20.800167999685687, "n": 240 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "may_peak", "rmse": 8.388434673785248, "mae": 6.815049103640856, "bias": 5.756467785570515, "n": 240 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "june_peak", "rmse": 8.14030138503696, "mae": 6.84772643109185, "bias": -3.493940192138832, "n": 205 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "june_peak", "rmse": 13.150889970351802, "mae": 12.638700059491583, "bias": 12.638700059491583, "n": 205 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "june_peak", "rmse": 13.997797806563796, "mae": 10.764003432224655, "bias": 10.387099654201101, "n": 205 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "june_peak", "rmse": 19.61042612858757, "mae": 14.643841425593822, "bias": 14.357365722174398, "n": 205 }, { "source": "OMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "june_peak", "rmse": 11.434479797454404, "mae": 8.607843931171557, "bias": 8.420900251155349, "n": 205 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "june_peak", "rmse": 9.235235630054566, "mae": 7.836998078722136, "bias": -2.6178445140959155, "n": 240 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "june_peak", "rmse": 14.31666892746077, "mae": 12.939480745620319, "bias": 12.939480745620319, "n": 240 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "june_peak", "rmse": 14.923282772969356, "mae": 11.202512755302957, "bias": 10.794998702066792, "n": 240 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "june_peak", "rmse": 20.26621437900005, "mae": 15.292596664460868, "bias": 14.627200883127578, "n": 240 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "june_peak", "rmse": 12.943375466158566, "mae": 9.409619451074592, "bias": 8.73674917271018, "n": 240 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "june_peak", "rmse": 10.753549797011559, "mae": 8.166737422091401, "bias": -6.468071385328343, "n": 240 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Climatology", "lead": 0, "group": "june_peak", "rmse": 9.959003539779276, "mae": 9.19494987716793, "bias": 9.089253874387891, "n": 240 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "GFS", "lead": 0, "group": "june_peak", "rmse": 11.273001237609357, "mae": 9.656454604244816, "bias": 6.944771830834366, "n": 240 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "june_peak", "rmse": 16.91176903942006, "mae": 12.332271722606016, "bias": 10.776974011895152, "n": 240 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "june_peak", "rmse": 8.390235079262286, "mae": 6.797749827483279, "bias": 4.886522301477753, "n": 240 } ], "operational": [ { "city": "Moscow", "label": "Москва", "tcoscope": { "n": 40, "bias_du": -1.9693214416503906, "mae_du": 5.879172515869141, "rmse_du": 7.366840669026857, "correlation": 0.939039442257576, "r2": 0.7813741983278262 }, "cams": { "n": 40, "bias_du": -12.566612243652344, "mae_du": 13.262907409667969, "rmse_du": 16.32141874420381, "correlation": 0.7562439395323909, "r2": -0.073135780856737 }, "comparison": { "tcoscope_rmse_reduction_vs_cams": 0.5486396872426897, "tcoscope_absolute_error_wins": 29, "matched_cases": 40 } }, { "city": "Sochi", "label": "Сочи", "tcoscope": { "n": 40, "bias_du": 5.89989013671875, "mae_du": 6.052229309082032, "rmse_du": 7.664782697950671, "correlation": 0.3869035880124136, "r2": -5.460090433519128 }, "cams": { "n": 40, "bias_du": -10.355812072753906, "mae_du": 10.355812072753906, "rmse_du": 10.74847781018262, "correlation": 0.6851441626195889, "r2": -11.703776146712508 }, "comparison": { "tcoscope_rmse_reduction_vs_cams": 0.28689598347689726, "tcoscope_absolute_error_wins": 29, "matched_cases": 40 } }, { "city": "Saint Petersburg", "label": "Санкт-Петербург", "tcoscope": { "n": 40, "bias_du": 1.3470413208007812, "mae_du": 5.467864990234375, "rmse_du": 7.009705359904558, "correlation": 0.872256594416013, "r2": 0.6356502726932456 }, "cams": { "n": 40, "bias_du": -12.684606170654297, "mae_du": 12.835150909423827, "rmse_du": 15.299367628489492, "correlation": 0.7449988842778315, "r2": -0.7356649063507688 }, "comparison": { "tcoscope_rmse_reduction_vs_cams": 0.5418303860578173, "tcoscope_absolute_error_wins": 30, "matched_cases": 40 } } ], "extended": { "rows": [ { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 13.208869824040248, "mae": 8.346527451598941, "bias": -2.2712987748783213, "n": 17945645 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 28.593300787103665, "mae": 18.099927394791838, "bias": 7.430990010498137, "n": 17945645 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 14.194806369720096, "mae": 10.271794450525435, "bias": 5.688225408498965, "n": 17945645 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 15.7933269103786, "mae": 11.570892345767122, "bias": -9.1878109014715, "n": 17123916 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 24.607781563469274, "mae": 14.321366914813359, "bias": 0.22231020624738698, "n": 17123916 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2025", "rmse": 10.687847137569483, "mae": 6.92505627381602, "bias": -1.3193538998816245, "n": 17123916 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 14.41557513700812, "mae": 9.537997377697971, "bias": -3.47998007843727, "n": 49424839 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 24.069141576589338, "mae": 15.619423268148664, "bias": 6.267414553608186, "n": 49424839 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 12.398915892289649, "mae": 9.114419379046046, "bias": 5.4937128389664975, "n": 49424839 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 16.40987707817191, "mae": 12.371070397072518, "bias": -9.365401662674236, "n": 53312853 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 22.652106477903175, "mae": 13.57519780429458, "bias": 0.21757113863634212, "n": 53312853 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 0, "group": "2026", "rmse": 9.974877076243562, "mae": 6.529782200797869, "bias": -0.5664590524057008, "n": 53312853 } ], "ground": [ { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "", "rmse": 15.772948432830871, "mae": 10.844654053425101, "bias": 0.3348772773690353, "n": 5832 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "", "rmse": 20.81054025752656, "mae": 15.010491146406848, "bias": -9.976148083115147, "n": 5832 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "", "rmse": 27.730850519174556, "mae": 18.458006315924667, "bias": 0.8203260989509663, "n": 5832 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "", "rmse": 16.42658681120047, "mae": 11.519691669351777, "bias": 0.16089211725544106, "n": 5807 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "", "rmse": 21.075553878784014, "mae": 15.22517056945517, "bias": -9.98573871268983, "n": 5807 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "", "rmse": 32.948074269783284, "mae": 22.773341494442494, "bias": 0.7420078688158894, "n": 5807 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "", "rmse": 17.152845873190827, "mae": 12.224053593595487, "bias": 0.08937023993328409, "n": 5783 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "", "rmse": 21.351186538507395, "mae": 15.420301377416665, "bias": -9.96994971549575, "n": 5783 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "", "rmse": 34.57838224023314, "mae": 24.452472472648477, "bias": 0.595963480100281, "n": 5783 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "", "rmse": 18.364566128129564, "mae": 13.14232012402123, "bias": 0.02918051394929427, "n": 5759 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "", "rmse": 22.028229387127897, "mae": 15.911085118914585, "bias": -9.743233719839157, "n": 5759 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "", "rmse": 35.143101744400255, "mae": 24.941459919922387, "bias": 0.43965971559715655, "n": 5759 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "", "rmse": 20.076254517728625, "mae": 14.43822045811138, "bias": -0.211204386946836, "n": 5733 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "", "rmse": 23.601819743448186, "mae": 16.91155435165227, "bias": -9.635205817509547, "n": 5733 }, { "source": "Brewer", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "", "rmse": 36.01426862043724, "mae": 25.872712919646776, "bias": 0.34172627894682545, "n": 5733 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "", "rmse": 19.33756694707614, "mae": 12.954188658333397, "bias": 5.522872172546626, "n": 6357 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "", "rmse": 20.81011780177831, "mae": 14.457987907185238, "bias": -3.0898670099920618, "n": 6357 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "", "rmse": 26.52940829086182, "mae": 17.750091944465442, "bias": 6.507454338751819, "n": 6357 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "", "rmse": 19.33163047597242, "mae": 13.143318782182874, "bias": 5.025415511346865, "n": 6326 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "", "rmse": 20.93069278693208, "mae": 14.572912238739429, "bias": -3.2532770398670916, "n": 6326 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "", "rmse": 29.910735443132467, "mae": 20.42215220631959, "bias": 6.282593083147982, "n": 6326 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "", "rmse": 19.70247496999309, "mae": 13.501567316600601, "bias": 4.852735437007841, "n": 6296 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "", "rmse": 21.11434849444901, "mae": 14.676709031392233, "bias": -3.2143164371747384, "n": 6296 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "", "rmse": 32.18852712816067, "mae": 22.224969489692587, "bias": 6.214556414108567, "n": 6296 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "", "rmse": 20.201798886181052, "mae": 13.937394461703967, "bias": 4.735668531440644, "n": 6275 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "", "rmse": 21.458131176916993, "mae": 14.921655972788534, "bias": -3.291374047754296, "n": 6275 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "", "rmse": 33.23760247169378, "mae": 23.119038287280564, "bias": 6.185324159417019, "n": 6275 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "", "rmse": 21.047971761756372, "mae": 14.661176398299709, "bias": 4.778295422927644, "n": 6251 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "", "rmse": 22.401847692657057, "mae": 15.543066979400482, "bias": -3.373530690167699, "n": 6251 }, { "source": "Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "", "rmse": 33.73227157321301, "mae": 23.502790732193784, "bias": 6.151774904491843, "n": 6251 }, { "source": "Brewer + Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 1, "group": "", "rmse": 17.721710584644164, "mae": 11.944851894380227, "bias": 3.0406024023705895, "n": 12189 }, { "source": "Brewer + Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 1, "group": "", "rmse": 20.810319932795306, "mae": 14.722340921471924, "bias": -6.384705899027573, "n": 12189 }, { "source": "Brewer + Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 1, "group": "", "rmse": 27.11089920452102, "mae": 18.088803620103327, "bias": 3.78636713762633, "n": 12189 }, { "source": "Brewer + Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 2, "group": "", "rmse": 17.999836342277327, "mae": 12.36623128162982, "bias": 2.697195998490284, "n": 12133 }, { "source": "Brewer + Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 2, "group": "", "rmse": 21.000149731104578, "mae": 14.885090935390407, "bias": -6.475514321172758, "n": 12133 }, { "source": "Brewer + Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 2, "group": "", "rmse": 31.40112074485858, "mae": 21.5474597309326, "bias": 3.6308022367269435, "n": 12133 }, { "source": "Brewer + Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 3, "group": "", "rmse": 18.525637300618236, "mae": 12.889938716539453, "bias": 2.572203858675018, "n": 12079 }, { "source": "Brewer + Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 3, "group": "", "rmse": 21.228067915026166, "mae": 15.032714871036184, "bias": -6.448675841805121, "n": 12079 }, { "source": "Brewer + Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 3, "group": "", "rmse": 33.354078325675594, "mae": 23.29141950628617, "bias": 3.5245719007076297, "n": 12079 }, { "source": "Brewer + Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 4, "group": "", "rmse": 19.344355002011646, "mae": 13.556903094684282, "bias": 2.483328121540969, "n": 12034 }, { "source": "Brewer + Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 4, "group": "", "rmse": 21.732823805163996, "mae": 15.3951579216451, "bias": -6.378980816205078, "n": 12034 }, { "source": "Brewer + Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 4, "group": "", "rmse": 34.16276316991673, "mae": 23.991177740694578, "bias": 3.435674705207398, "n": 12034 }, { "source": "Brewer + Dobson", "system": "TCOscope", "lead": 5, "group": "", "rmse": 20.588836807096875, "mae": 14.5545169853241, "bias": 2.391379333974841, "n": 11984 }, { "source": "Brewer + Dobson", "system": "CAMS", "lead": 5, "group": "", "rmse": 22.98371770719792, "mae": 16.197734711803644, "bias": -6.369039994661258, "n": 11984 }, { "source": "Brewer + Dobson", "system": "Persistence", "lead": 5, "group": "", "rmse": 34.84260358995608, "mae": 24.63653271322416, "bias": 3.372318231406931, "n": 11984 } ], "coverage": { "satellite_overall": [ { "source": "OMPS", "system": "CAMS", "n": 67370484, "weight": 46725649.473059535, "sse": 9292790242.586525, "sae": 430756834.6887432, "se": -147476626.43029433, "rmse": 14.102476796743545, "mae": 9.218851734465527, "bias": -3.156224217179142 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Persistence", "n": 67370484, "weight": 46725649.473059535, "sse": 30051218305.237442, "sae": 760873373.6766974, "se": 307412179.3291752, "rmse": 25.360240533856217, "mae": 16.28384799906081, "bias": 6.579088419229333 }, { "source": "OMPS", "system": "Модель", "n": 67370484, "weight": 46725649.473059535, "sse": 7781030447.603268, "sae": 440362725.60821295, "se": 259131795.22870678, "rmse": 12.904491147743496, "mae": 9.424432417191152, "bias": 5.545814732401175 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "CAMS", "n": 70436769, "weight": 47915345.42095717, "sse": 12671515902.795927, "sae": 583441487.1142931, "se": -446677401.26280653, "rmse": 16.262113011798057, "mae": 12.176505918688587, "bias": -9.32222020604362 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Persistence", "n": 70436769, "weight": 47915345.42095717, "sse": 25663037353.884274, "sae": 659153674.8633368, "se": 10480209.655796679, "rmse": 23.1428433868973, "mae": 13.756629928729195, "bias": 0.21872344994538753 }, { "source": "TROPOMI", "system": "Модель", "n": 70436769, "weight": 47915345.42095717, "sse": 4939126115.615965, "sae": 317481984.26197684, "se": -35913823.53313725, "rmse": 10.152844769008261, "mae": 6.625893677124925, "bias": -0.7495265497434834 } ], "ground_stations": 72, "ground_rows": 60419, "matched_initializations": 354, "initializations": 354, "station_selection": { "Brewer": { "id": 96, "name": "Hradec Králové", "dates": 334, "lat": 50.177, "lon": 15.839 }, "Dobson": { "id": 2, "name": "Tamanrasset", "dates": 334, "lat": 22.8, "lon": 5.52 } }, "city_metrics": [ { "city": "Москва", "system": "model", "n": 1725, "rmse": 15.376870113989455, "bias": -1.626573291723279 }, { "city": "Москва", "system": "cams", "n": 1725, "rmse": 21.716054041125343, "bias": -12.719420042176177 }, { "city": "Сочи", "system": "model", "n": 1725, "rmse": 12.106561508852412, "bias": 2.4171173449530117 }, { "city": "Сочи", "system": "cams", "n": 1725, "rmse": 17.971558489609617, "bias": -11.831803235040194 } ] } } }